Jouyaux F, De Crevoisier R, Manens J-P, Bellec J, Cazoulat G, Haigron P, Chira C, Le Prisé E, Lafond C
Centre Eugène-Marquis, rue de La Bataille-Flandres-Dunkerque, CS 44229, 35042 Rennes cedex, France.
Cancer Radiother. 2010 Dec;14(8):679-89. doi: 10.1016/j.canrad.2010.03.003. Epub 2010 May 31.
To compare two Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT) techniques for prostate cancer: the Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT) and the "Step and Shoot" technique (S&S).
VMAT and S&S plans (RX 18MV) were created and compared (Wilcoxon test) for 10 patients. The dosimetric goal of both treatments was to deliver 46 Gy to the seminal vesicles and 80 Gy to the prostate, while respecting the dose constrains in the organs at risk of toxicity. For one patient, the two techniques were compared for dose painting and escalation in target volumes defined on MRI and registered thanks to intraprostatic fiducials.
VMAT, compared to S&S, offered: an increase of the PTV2s (prostate) volume receiving 77 to 80 Gy and a decrease of V(82) and V(83); a decrease of V(4) to V(6), V(16) to V(23), and V(69) to V(73) for the rectal wall; a decrease of V(25) for the bladder wall; a decrease of V(21) to V(43) for the femoral heads; a decrease of V(26) to V(44) and V(72) to V(80) but an increase of V(1) to V(21) and V(49) to V(60) for the healthy tissues. The Conformal Index "COIN" was better with VMAT than S&S (0.60 to 0.66). The delivered MU were significantly reduced with VMAT (8% mean) as well as the delivery time (4 min to 1.5 min). VMAT allowed delivering theorically 90Gy in the peripheral zone and 100 Gy in the tumor.
In case of prostate irradiation, VMAT shows improvement compared with S&S. In particular, organs at risk are better spared, the delivery time is shortened and the number of delivered UM is decreased.
比较两种用于前列腺癌的调强放射治疗(IMRT)技术:容积调强弧形治疗(VMAT)和“步进式”技术(S&S)。
为10例患者创建并比较了VMAT和S&S计划(RX 18MV)(Wilcoxon检验)。两种治疗的剂量学目标是向精囊给予46 Gy,向前列腺给予80 Gy,同时遵守对有中毒风险器官的剂量限制。对于一名患者,比较了两种技术在基于MRI定义并通过前列腺内基准标记配准的靶区内的剂量勾画和剂量递增情况。
与S&S相比,VMAT表现为:接受77至80 Gy照射的PTV2s(前列腺)体积增加,V(82)和V(83)减小;直肠壁的V(4)至V(6)、V(16)至V(23)以及V(69)至V(73)减小;膀胱壁的V(25)减小;股骨头的V(21)至V(43)减小;健康组织的V(26)至V(44)和V(72)至V(80)减小,但V(1)至V(21)和V(49)至V(60)增加。适形指数“COIN”在VMAT时比S&S更好(0.60至0.66)。VMAT显著减少了所输送的MU(平均减少8%)以及输送时间(从4分钟减至1.5分钟)。VMAT理论上能够在外周区给予90 Gy,在肿瘤区给予100 Gy。
在前列腺放疗中,VMAT与S&S相比有改进。特别是,对危及器官的保护更好,输送时间缩短,所输送的MU数量减少。