Mann V, Soli S D
Department of Cognitive Sciences, School of Social Science, University of California, Irvine 92717.
Percept Psychophys. 1991 May;49(5):399-411. doi: 10.3758/bf03212174.
This three-part study demonstrates that perceptual order can influence the integration of acoustic speech cues. In Experiment 1, the subjects labeled the [s] and [sh] in natural FV and VF syllables in which the frication was replaced with synthetic stimuli. Responses to these "hybrid" stimuli were influenced by cues in the vocalic segment as well as by the synthetic frication. However, the influence of the preceding vocalic cues was considerably weaker than was that of the following vocalic cues. Experiment 2 examined the acoustic bases for this asymmetry and consisted of analyses revealing that FV and VF syllables are similar in terms of the acoustic structures thought to underlie the vocalic context effects. Experiment 3 examined the perceptual bases for the asymmetry. A subset of the hybrid FV and VF stimuli were presented in reverse, such that the acoustic and perceptual bases for the asymmetry were pitted against each other in the listening task. The perceptual bases (i.e., the perceived order of the frication and vocalic cues) proved to be the determining factor. Current auditory processing models, such as backward recognition masking, preperceptual auditory storage, or models based on linguistic factors, do not adequately account for the observed asymmetries.
这项分为三个部分的研究表明,感知顺序会影响语音线索的整合。在实验1中,受试者对自然的FV和VF音节中的[s]和[sh]进行标注,其中摩擦音被合成刺激所取代。对这些“混合”刺激的反应受到元音段线索以及合成摩擦音的影响。然而,先前元音线索的影响远弱于后续元音线索的影响。实验2研究了这种不对称性的声学基础,分析表明FV和VF音节在被认为是元音语境效应基础的声学结构方面相似。实验3研究了这种不对称性的感知基础。一部分混合的FV和VF刺激以相反的顺序呈现,这样在听力任务中,不对称性的声学和感知基础相互对立。结果证明,感知基础(即摩擦音和元音线索的感知顺序)是决定性因素。当前的听觉处理模型,如反向识别掩蔽、感知前听觉存储或基于语言因素的模型,都无法充分解释所观察到的不对称性。