Brooke M M, de Lateur B J, Diana-Rigby G C, Questad K A
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Tufts University, Boston, MA 02111.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1991 Jul;72(8):582-6.
Shoulder subluxation in hemiplegia is a difficult problem to manage and it may be associated with pain and other complications. Measurements taken from x-rays have been used to obtain objective measures of shoulder subluxation, but have not been used to compare the effects of different shoulder supports. This study used x-ray measurements to evaluate different shoulder supports for subluxation in hemiplegia and to see if there was a significant difference between the Harris hemisling and the Bobath sling. The Harris hemisling gave good vertical correction of subluxation and compared closely to the uninvolved shoulder. The Bobath sling did not correct the subluxation as well, and the mean difference between the two slings was significant. The arm trough or lap board was less effective and tended to overcorrect. The Harris hemisling and arm trough or lap board had horizontal measurements similar to the uninvolved shoulders. The Bobath sling, however, distracted the glenohumeral joint horizontally and was more variable. The mean horizontal difference between the Harris hemisling and the Bobath sling was significant. These results support the effectiveness and specificity of shoulder support to decrease subluxation after hemiplegia.
偏瘫患者的肩关节半脱位是一个难以处理的问题,可能会伴有疼痛及其他并发症。通过X线测量已用于获取肩关节半脱位的客观指标,但尚未用于比较不同肩部支撑器具的效果。本研究采用X线测量来评估不同的肩部支撑器具对偏瘫患者半脱位的作用,并观察哈里斯半悬吊带与鲍巴斯吊带之间是否存在显著差异。哈里斯半悬吊带能很好地垂直矫正半脱位,与未受累侧肩部情况相近。鲍巴斯吊带对半脱位的矫正效果较差,两种吊带之间的平均差异具有显著性。手臂托板或腿上板效果欠佳且有过度矫正的倾向。哈里斯半悬吊带和手臂托板或腿上板的水平测量结果与未受累侧肩部相似。然而,鲍巴斯吊带会使盂肱关节在水平方向上分离,且变化更大。哈里斯半悬吊带与鲍巴斯吊带之间的平均水平差异具有显著性。这些结果证实了肩部支撑器具在减轻偏瘫后半脱位方面的有效性和特异性。