Department of Community Health, Boonshoft School of Medicine, Wright State University, Dayton, Ohio, USA.
Med Educ. 2010 Jun;44(6):570-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2010.03633.x.
OBJECTIVES Three domains comprise the field of human assessment: ability, motive and personality. Differences in personality and cognitive abilities between generations have been documented, but differences in motive between generations have not been explored. This study explored generational differences in medical students regarding motives using the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT). METHODS Four hundred and twenty six students (97% response rate) at one medical school (Generation X = 229, Millennials = 197) who matriculated in 1995 & 1996 (Generation X) or in 2003 & 2004 (Millennials) wrote a story after being shown two TAT picture cards. Student stories for each TAT card were scored for different aspects of motives: Achievement, Affiliation, and Power. RESULTS A multiple analysis of variance (p < 0.05) showed significant differences between Millennials' and Generation X-ers' needs for Power on both TAT cards and needs for Achievement and Affiliation on one TAT card. The main effect for gender was significant for both TAT cards regarding Achievement. No main effect for ethnicity was noted. CONCLUSIONS Differences in needs for Achievement, Affiliation and Power exist between Millennial and Generation X medical students. Generation X-ers scored higher on the motive of Power, whereas Millennials scored higher on the motives of Achievement and Affiliation.
人类评估领域包括三个方面:能力、动机和个性。已经记录了代际之间在个性和认知能力方面的差异,但尚未探讨代际之间在动机方面的差异。本研究使用主题统觉测验(TAT)探讨了医学生在动机方面的代际差异。
在一所医学院(X 世代=229,千禧一代=197)中,有 426 名学生(97%的回复率)在 1995 年和 1996 年(X 世代)或 2003 年和 2004 年(千禧一代)入学,他们在观看了两张 TAT 图片卡后写了一个故事。对每个 TAT 卡的学生故事进行了不同动机方面的评分:成就、归属和权力。
多元方差分析(p<0.05)显示,在两张 TAT 卡上,千禧一代和 X 世代的学生在权力需求方面存在显著差异,在一张 TAT 卡上在成就和归属需求方面存在显著差异。在成就方面,性别对两张 TAT 卡都有显著的主效应。种族没有显著的主效应。
千禧一代和 X 世代医学生在成就、归属和权力需求方面存在差异。X 世代在权力动机方面得分较高,而千禧一代在成就和归属动机方面得分较高。