Stroke Prevention Research Unit (M.F.G., P.M.R.), National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre, Oxford, UK.
Stroke. 2010 Sep;41(9):1907-13. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.110.578971. Epub 2010 Jul 15.
The ABCD system was developed to predict early stroke risk after transient ischemic attack. Incorporation of brain imaging findings has been suggested, but reports have used inconsistent methods and been underpowered. We therefore performed an international, multicenter collaborative study of the prognostic performance of the ABCD(2) score and brain infarction on imaging to determine the optimal weighting of infarction in the score (ABCD(2)I).
Twelve centers provided unpublished data on ABCD(2) scores, presence of brain infarction on either diffusion-weighted imaging or CT, and follow-up in cohorts of patients with transient ischemic attack diagnosed by World Health Organization criteria. Optimal weighting of infarction in the ABCD(2)I score was determined using area under the receiver operating characteristic curve analyses and random effects meta-analysis.
Among 4574 patients with TIA, acute infarction was present in 884 (27.6%) of 3206 imaged with diffusion-weighted imaging and new or old infarction was present in 327 (23.9%) of 1368 imaged with CT. ABCD(2) score and presence of infarction on diffusion-weighted imaging or CT were both independently predictive of stroke (n=145) at 7 days (after adjustment for ABCD(2) score, OR for infarction=6.2, 95% CI=4.2 to 9.0, overall; 14.9, 7.4 to 30.2, for diffusion-weighted imaging; 4.2, 2.6 to 6.9, for CT; all P<0.001). Incorporation of infarction in the ABCD(2)I score improved predictive power with an optimal weighting of 3 points for infarction on CT or diffusion-weighted imaging. Pooled areas under the curve increased from 0.66 (0.53 to 0.78) for the ABCD(2) score to 0.78 (0.72 to 0.85) for the ABCD(2)I score.
In secondary care, incorporation of brain infarction into the ABCD system (ABCD(2)I score) improves prediction of stroke in the acute phase after transient ischemic attack.
ABCD 系统旨在预测短暂性脑缺血发作后早期卒中风险。已有研究提出将脑部影像学结果纳入其中,但这些报告所采用的方法并不一致,且效力不足。因此,我们开展了一项 ABCD(2)评分和脑梗死影像学表现的国际多中心合作研究,旨在确定评分中梗死的最佳权重(ABCD(2)I)。
12 个中心提供了未发表的 ABCD(2)评分、弥散加权成像或 CT 上是否存在脑梗死以及符合世界卫生组织标准的短暂性脑缺血发作患者队列随访数据。采用受试者工作特征曲线下面积分析和随机效应荟萃分析确定 ACD(2)I 评分中梗死的最佳权重。
在 4574 例 TIA 患者中,3206 例行弥散加权成像的患者中有 884 例(27.6%)存在急性梗死,1368 例行 CT 的患者中有 327 例(23.9%)存在新旧梗死。ABCD(2)评分和弥散加权成像或 CT 上存在梗死均独立预测 7 天内卒中(校正 ABCD(2)评分后,OR 为 6.2,95%CI 为 4.2 至 9.0,整体;OR 为 14.9,95%CI 为 7.4 至 30.2,弥散加权成像;OR 为 4.2,95%CI 为 2.6 至 6.9,CT;均 P<0.001)。在 ABCD(2)I 评分中纳入梗死可提高预测能力,CT 或弥散加权成像上的梗死最佳权重为 3 分。曲线下面积从 ABCD(2)评分的 0.66(0.53 至 0.78)增加至 ABCD(2)I 评分的 0.78(0.72 至 0.85)。
在二级医疗环境中,将脑梗死纳入 ABCD 系统(ABCD(2)I 评分)可改善短暂性脑缺血发作后急性期中的卒中预测。