Juillerat Pascal, Pittet Valérie, Mottet Christian, Felley Christian, Gonvers Jean-Jacques, Vader John-Paul, Burnand Bernard, Froehlich Florian, Wolters Frank L, Stockbrügger Reinhold W, Michetti Pierre
Department of Gastroenterology & Hepatology, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois and University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Scand J Gastroenterol. 2010 Dec;45(12):1449-56. doi: 10.3109/00365521.2010.505660. Epub 2010 Jul 26.
The European Panel on the Appropriateness of Crohn's disease Therapy (EPACT) has developed appropriateness criteria. We have applied these criteria retrospectively to the population-based inception cohort of Crohn's disease (CD) patients of the European Collaborative Study Group on Inflammatory Bowel Disease (EC-IBD).
A total of 426 diagnosed CD patients from 13 European centers were enrolled at the time of diagnosis (first flare, naive patients). We used the EPACT definitions to identify 247 patients with active luminal CD. We then assessed the appropriateness of the initial drug prescription according to the EPACT criteria.
Among the cohort patients 163 suffered from mild-to-moderate CD and 84 from severe CD. Among the mild-to-moderate disease group, 96 patients (59%) received an appropriate treatment, whereas for 66 patients (40%) the treatment was uncertain and in one case (1%) inappropriate. Among the severe disease group, 86% were treated medically and 14% required surgery. 59 (70%) were appropriately treated, whereas for one patient (1%) the procedure was considered uncertain and for 24 patients (29%) inappropriate.
Initial treatment was appropriate in the majority of cases for non-complicated luminal CD. Inappropriate or uncertain treatment was given in a significant minority of patients, with an increased potential risk of adverse events.
欧洲克罗恩病治疗适宜性小组(EPACT)制定了适宜性标准。我们将这些标准回顾性应用于欧洲炎症性肠病协作研究组(EC-IBD)以人群为基础的克罗恩病(CD)初发病例队列。
来自13个欧洲中心的共426例确诊CD患者在诊断时(首次发作,初治患者)入组。我们使用EPACT的定义确定了247例活动性肠腔型CD患者。然后根据EPACT标准评估初始药物处方的适宜性。
在队列患者中,163例患有轻至中度CD,84例患有重度CD。在轻至中度疾病组中,96例患者(59%)接受了适当治疗,而66例患者(40%)的治疗不明确,1例患者(1%)治疗不当。在重度疾病组中,86%接受药物治疗,14%需要手术。59例(70%)得到适当治疗,而1例患者(1%)的治疗过程被认为不明确,24例患者(29%)治疗不当。
对于非复杂性肠腔型CD,大多数病例的初始治疗是适当的。少数患者接受了不适当或不明确的治疗,不良事件潜在风险增加。