Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, 3216 Institute for Human Performance, 750 East Adams Street, Syracuse, NY 13210, USA.
J Biomech. 2010 Oct 19;43(14):2738-46. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2010.06.017. Epub 2010 Jul 23.
Insufficiency fracture following radiation therapy (RTx) is a challenging clinical problem and typical bone mass measures fail to predict these fractures. The goals of this research were to develop a mouse model that results in reduced bone strength following focal irradiation, quantify morphological and strength changes occurring over time, and determine if a positive correlation between bone morphology and strength is retained after irradiation. Right hind limbs of 13 week-old female Balb/c mice were irradiated (5 or 20 Gy) using a therapeutic X-ray unit. Left limbs served as control. Animals were euthanized at 2, 6, 12, or 26 weeks. Axial compression tests of the distal femur were used to quantify whole bone strength. Specimen-specific, non-linear finite element (FE) analyses of the mechanical tests were performed using voxel-based meshes with two different material failure models: a linear bone density-strength relationship and a non-linear 'embrittled' relationship. Radiation resulted in a dose dependent increase in cortical bone density and marked loss of trabecular bone, measured using micro-CT. An early (2 week) increase in bone volume was associated with an increase in bone strength following irradiation; at 12 weeks there was a loss of bone strength despite higher bone volume for irradiated limbs. There was a positive correlation between bone volume bone and strength in control (r²=0.63) but not irradiated femora (r²=0.08). FE analysis with a constant strain failure model resulted in improved prediction of bone strength for irradiated limbs (r²=0.34) and this was improved further with the embrittled material model (r²=0.46). In summary, focal irradiation leads to substantial changes in bone morphology and strength with time, where there is a decreased bone strength following irradiation in the face of increasing bone mass; FE models with a non-linear embrittled material model were most successful in simulating these experimental findings.
放射治疗(RTx)后发生的骨量不足是一个具有挑战性的临床问题,典型的骨量测量方法无法预测这些骨折。本研究的目的是开发一种可导致焦点照射后骨强度降低的小鼠模型,定量分析随时间发生的形态和强度变化,并确定照射后骨形态与强度之间是否存在正相关。对 13 周龄雌性 Balb/c 小鼠的右侧后肢进行放射治疗(5 或 20 Gy),使用治疗用 X 射线装置。左侧肢体作为对照。在 2、6、12 或 26 周时处死动物。使用远端股骨的轴向压缩试验来量化整个骨骼的强度。使用基于体素的网格对机械试验进行特定于标本的非线性有限元(FE)分析,并使用两种不同的材料失效模型:线性骨密度-强度关系和非线性“脆化”关系。辐射导致皮质骨密度呈剂量依赖性增加,使用微 CT 测量,骨小梁骨明显丢失。在照射后,早期(2 周)骨体积增加与骨强度增加相关;在 12 周时,尽管照射肢体的骨体积较高,但骨强度仍下降。在对照组(r²=0.63)中,骨体积与骨强度呈正相关,但在照射股骨中无相关性(r²=0.08)。FE 分析采用恒定应变失效模型可改善对照射肢体骨强度的预测(r²=0.34),采用脆化材料模型进一步改善(r²=0.46)。总之,焦点照射随时间导致骨形态和强度发生实质性变化,尽管骨量增加,但照射后骨强度下降;采用非线性脆化材料模型的 FE 模型最成功地模拟了这些实验结果。