Department of Neurosurgery, Center of Neurological Medicine, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany.
Neurosurg Rev. 2010 Oct;33(4):441-9. doi: 10.1007/s10143-010-0280-7. Epub 2010 Aug 13.
Randomized phase III trials have shown significant improvement of survival 1, 2, and 3 years after implantation of 1,3-bis (2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU) wafers for patients with newly diagnosed malignant glioma. But these studies and subsequent non-phase III studies have also shown risks associated with local chemotherapy within the central nervous system. The introduction of concomitant radiochemotherapy with temozolomide (TMZ) has later demonstrated a survival benefit in a phase III trial and has become the current treatment standard for newly diagnosed malignant glioma patients. Lately, this has resulted in clinical protocols combining local chemotherapy with BCNU wafers and concomitant radiochemotherapy with TMZ although this may carry the risk of increased toxicity. We have compiled the treatment experience of seven neurosurgical centers using implantation of carmustine wafers at primary surgery followed by 6 weeks of radiation therapy (59-60 Gy) and 75 mg/m(2)/day TMZ in patients with newly diagnosed glioblastoma followed by TMZ monochemotherapy. We have retrospectively analyzed the postoperative clinical course, occurrence and severity of adverse events, progression-free interval, and overall survival in 44 patients with newly diagnosed glioblastoma multiforme. All patients received multimodal treatment including tumor resection, BCNU wafer implantation, and concomitant radiochemotherapy. Of 44 patients (mean age 59 ± 10.8 years) with glioblastoma who received Gliadel wafer at primary surgery, 28 patients (64%) had died, 16 patients (36%) were alive, and 15 patients showed no evidence of clinical or radiographic progression after a median follow-up of 15.6 months. At time of analysis of adverse events in this patient population, the median overall survival was 12.7 months and median progression-free survival was 7.0 months. Surgical, neurological, and medical adverse events were analyzed. Twenty-three patients (52%) experienced adverse events of any kind including complications that did not require treatment. Nineteen patients (43%) experienced grade 3 or grade 4 adverse events. Surgical complications included cerebral edema, healing abnormalities, cerebral spinal fluid leakage, meningitis, intracranial abscess, and hydrocephalus. Neurological adverse events included newly diagnosed seizures, alteration of mental status, and new neurological deficits. Medical complications were thromboembolic events (thrombosis, pulmonary embolism) and hematotoxicity. Combination of both treatment strategies, local chemotherapy with BCNU wafer and concomitant radiochemotherapy, appears attractive in aggressive multimodal treatment schedules and may utilize the sensitizing effect of TMZ and carmustine on MGMT and AGT on their respective drug resistance genes. Our data demonstrate that combination of local chemotherapy and concomitant radiochemotherapy carries a significant risk of toxicity that currently appears underestimated. Adverse events observed in this study appear similar to complication rates published in the phase III trials for BCNU wafer implantation followed by radiation therapy alone, but further add the toxicity of concomitant radiochemotherapy with systemic TMZ. Save use of a combined approach will require specific prevention strategies for multimodal treatments.
随机 III 期临床试验表明,对于新诊断的恶性神经胶质瘤患者,植入 1,3-双(2-氯乙基)-1-亚硝基脲(BCNU)片后 1、2 和 3 年的生存率显著提高。但这些研究和随后的非 III 期研究也表明,中枢神经系统内局部化疗存在风险。随后,替莫唑胺(TMZ)同期放化疗的引入在 III 期试验中显示出生存获益,并已成为新诊断的恶性神经胶质瘤患者的当前治疗标准。最近,这导致了临床方案将局部化疗与 BCNU 片联合,并将同期放化疗与 TMZ 联合,尽管这可能会增加毒性。我们汇编了七个神经外科中心的治疗经验,在新诊断的多形性胶质母细胞瘤患者中,在初次手术后使用卡莫司汀片植入,然后进行 6 周的放射治疗(59-60Gy)和 75mg/m2/天 TMZ,然后进行 TMZ 单药化疗。我们回顾性分析了 44 例新诊断的多形性胶质母细胞瘤患者的术后临床过程、不良事件的发生和严重程度、无进展生存期和总生存期。所有患者均接受多模式治疗,包括肿瘤切除术、BCNU 片植入和同期放化疗。在 44 例(平均年龄 59±10.8 岁)接受Gliadel 片植入的多形性胶质母细胞瘤患者中,28 例(64%)死亡,16 例(36%)存活,15 例在中位随访 15.6 个月后无临床或影像学进展的证据。在分析该患者人群的不良事件时,中位总生存期为 12.7 个月,中位无进展生存期为 7.0 个月。分析了手术、神经和医学不良事件。23 名患者(52%)出现任何类型的不良事件,包括无需治疗的并发症。19 名患者(43%)发生 3 级或 4 级不良事件。手术并发症包括脑水肿、愈合异常、脑脊髓液漏、脑膜炎、颅内脓肿和脑积水。神经不良事件包括新诊断的癫痫发作、精神状态改变和新的神经功能缺损。医学并发症包括血栓栓塞事件(血栓形成、肺栓塞)和血液毒性。局部化疗联合 BCNU 片与同期放化疗相结合的治疗策略似乎在积极的多模式治疗方案中很有吸引力,并且可能利用 TMZ 和卡莫司汀对 MGMT 和 AGT 的增敏作用及其各自的耐药基因。我们的数据表明,局部化疗和同期放化疗的联合治疗具有显著的毒性风险,目前似乎被低估了。本研究观察到的不良事件与单独接受 BCNU 片植入和放射治疗的 III 期试验中公布的并发症发生率相似,但进一步增加了同期放化疗联合全身 TMZ 的毒性。只有通过特定的预防策略才能减少联合治疗方法的应用。