Shekelle Paul G, Newberry Sydne, Maglione Margaret, Li Zhaoping, Yermilov Irina, Hilton Lara, Suttorp Marika, Maggard Melinda, Carter Jason, Tringale Carlo, Chen Susan
Southern California Evidence-based Practice Center, Santa Monica, CA, USA.
Evid Rep Technol Assess (Full Rep). 2008 Nov(169):1-51.
The use of bariatric surgery for treating severe obesity has increased dramatically over the past 10 years; about half of patients who undergo these procedures are women of reproductive age. This report was commissioned to measure the incidence of bariatric surgery in this population and review the evidence on the impact of bariatric surgery on fertility and subsequent pregnancy.
To measure the incidence of contemporary bariatric surgery procedures in women age 18-45 and to assess its impact on fertility, contraception, prepregnancy risk factors, and pregnancy outcomes, including those of neonates.
Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS), a national sample of over 1,000 hospitals, to measure the trend in the number of women of reproductive age who underwent bariatric procedures from 1998-2005. We searched numerous electronic databases, including MEDLINE and Embase, for potentially relevant studies involving bariatric surgery (gastric bypass, laparoscopic adjustable gastric band, vertical-banded gastroplasty, biliopancreatic diversion), and consequent fertility, contraception, pregnancy, weight management, maternal and neonatal outcomes, and nutritional deficiencies. We scanned reference lists for additional relevant articles and contacted experts in the fields of bariatric surgery and obstetrics/gynecology (OB/GYN). Of 223 screened articles, we accepted 57 that reported on fertility following surgery (19 articles), contraception use/recommendations (11), maternal weight or nutrition management (28), maternal outcomes including morbidity and mortality (48), cesarean-section rates (16), and neonatal outcomes (44). These articles included reports on gastric bypass, both open and laparoscopic (27 articles), laparoscopic adjustable band (15), biliopancreatic diversion (16), and vertical-banded gastroplasty (6). Studies could contribute to one or more analyses. We found one case-control study and the observational data accepted included 12 cohort studies, 21 case series, and 23 individual case reports.
We abstracted information about study design, fertility history, fertility outcomes, prepregnancy weight loss, nutritional management, outcomes following pregnancy, and adverse events (during pregnancy) related to surgery.
Nationally representative data showed a six-fold increase in bariatric surgery inpatient procedures from 1998 to 2005. Women age 18-45 accounted for about half of the patients undergoing bariatric surgery; over 50,000 have these procedures as inpatients annually. An unknown number have outpatient bariatric procedures. We identified one case-control study that directly addressed some of the key questions, but no randomized controlled trials or prospective cohort studies, which would be the strongest study designs to answer questions about effectiveness, risk and prognosis. Consequently, all of our conclusions are limited by the available data, and are cautious.The evidence suggests that bariatric surgery results in improved fertility; the strongest evidence is in women with the polycystic ovarian syndrome, where biochemical studies showing normalization of hormones after surgery support case series data. Observational studies (retrospective cohorts and case series) suggest that fertility improves following bariatric procedures and weight loss; similar to that seen when obese women lose weight through nonsurgical means. There is almost no evidence on post-surgical contraceptive efficacy or use. Research is needed to determine whether differences in absorption, particularly for oral contraceptives, affect contraceptive efficacy. Nutrient deficiencies were reported in infants born to women who underwent procedures that resulted in malabsorption, as well as women who did not take prenatal vitamins or had difficulty with their own nutrition (i.e., from chronic vomiting). Literature suggests that gastric bypass and laparoscopic adjustable band procedures confer only minimal, if any, increased risk of nutritional or congenital problems if supplemental vitamins are taken and maternal nutrition is otherwise adequate. Biliopancreatic diversion has an appreciable risk for nutritional problems in some patients. Women who have undergone bariatric surgery may have less risk than obese women for certain pregnancy complications such as gestational diabetes, preeclampsia, and pregnancy induced hypertension. There is no evidence that cesarean section rates and delivery complications are higher in the post-surgery group, but data are limited.
Weight loss procedures are being performed more frequently to treat morbid obesity, with a six-fold increase over a recent 7-year time span; almost half of all patients are women of reproductive age. The level of evidence on fertility, contraception, and pregnancy outcomes is limited to observational studies. Data suggest that fertility improves after bariatric surgical procedures, nutritional deficiencies for mother and child are minimal, and maternal and neonatal outcomes are acceptable with laparoscopic adjustable band and gastric bypass as long as adequate maternal nutrition and vitamin supplementation are maintained. There is no evidence that delivery complications are higher in post-surgery pregnancies.
在过去10年中,减肥手术用于治疗重度肥胖的情况急剧增加;接受这些手术的患者中约有一半是育龄妇女。本报告旨在衡量该人群中减肥手术的发生率,并综述减肥手术对生育能力和后续妊娠影响的证据。
衡量18 - 45岁女性中当代减肥手术的发生率,并评估其对生育能力、避孕、孕前危险因素及妊娠结局(包括新生儿结局)的影响。
全国住院患者样本(NIS),这是一个来自1000多家医院的全国性样本,用于衡量1998 - 2005年接受减肥手术的育龄妇女数量趋势。我们检索了众多电子数据库,包括MEDLINE和Embase,以查找涉及减肥手术(胃旁路术、腹腔镜可调节胃束带术、垂直带胃成形术、胆胰转流术)以及随之而来的生育能力、避孕、妊娠、体重管理、母婴结局和营养缺乏等潜在相关研究。我们浏览了参考文献列表以获取更多相关文章,并联系了减肥手术和妇产科领域的专家。在筛选的223篇文章中,我们纳入了57篇报告手术相关生育情况(19篇)、避孕使用/建议(11篇)、产妇体重或营养管理(28篇)、产妇结局(包括发病率和死亡率,48篇)、剖宫产率(16篇)以及新生儿结局(44篇)的文章。这些文章包括关于开放式和腹腔镜胃旁路术(27篇)、腹腔镜可调节束带术(15篇)、胆胰转流术(16篇)以及垂直带胃成形术(6篇)的报告。研究可对一项或多项分析有所贡献。我们发现一项病例对照研究,纳入观察数据包括12项队列研究、21项病例系列研究以及23份个案报告。
我们提取了关于研究设计、生育史、生育结局、孕前体重减轻、营养管理、妊娠结局以及与手术相关的不良事件(孕期)等信息。
具有全国代表性的数据显示1998年至2005年减肥手术住院病例增加了6倍。18 - 45岁女性约占接受减肥手术患者的一半;每年超过50000名患者住院接受此类手术。门诊减肥手术患者数量未知。我们发现一项直接针对部分关键问题的病例对照研究,但没有随机对照试验或前瞻性队列研究,而这两种研究设计是回答关于有效性、风险和预后问题的最强有力设计。因此,我们所有结论都受现有数据限制且较为谨慎。证据表明减肥手术可改善生育能力;最有力的证据来自多囊卵巢综合征女性,术后激素生化指标正常化的研究支持了病例系列数据。观察性研究(回顾性队列研究和病例系列研究)表明减肥手术后生育能力改善且体重减轻;这与肥胖女性通过非手术方式减肥后的情况相似。几乎没有关于术后避孕效果或使用情况的证据。需要开展研究以确定吸收差异,尤其是口服避孕药的吸收差异是否会影响避孕效果。报告显示,接受导致吸收不良手术的女性所生婴儿以及未服用产前维生素或自身营养有问题(如慢性呕吐)的女性所生婴儿存在营养缺乏情况。文献表明,如果补充维生素且产妇营养充足,胃旁路术和腹腔镜可调节束带术仅会带来极小的营养或先天性问题风险。胆胰转流术在部分患者中存在明显的营养问题风险。接受减肥手术的女性在某些妊娠并发症(如妊娠期糖尿病、先兆子痫和妊娠高血压)方面的风险可能低于肥胖女性。没有证据表明术后组剖宫产率和分娩并发症更高,但数据有限。
为治疗病态肥胖,减肥手术实施得越来越频繁,在最近7年时间里增加了6倍;所有患者中近一半是育龄妇女。关于生育能力、避孕和妊娠结局的证据水平仅限于观察性研究。数据表明减肥手术后生育能力改善,母婴营养缺乏情况极少,只要维持充足的产妇营养和维生素补充,腹腔镜可调节束带术和胃旁路术的母婴结局是可接受的。没有证据表明术后妊娠的分娩并发症更高。