Bradnock T J, Walker G M
Department of Paediatric Surgery, Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2011 Jan;93(1):34-8. doi: 10.1308/003588410X12771863936846. Epub 2010 Aug 24.
The management of Hirschsprung's disease continues to evolve. This questionnaire survey aimed to determine current surgical management strategies for Hirschsprung's disease in Britain.
The survey was sent electronically to all British paediatric surgeons. Initial questions explored individual experience and regional service provision. Additional questions, reserved for surgeons who perform definitive Hirschsprung's disease surgery, addressed specific clinical scenarios.
Surveys were sent to 142 surgeons yielding 85 responses. After exclusions, 64 surveys from 21 centres were analysed. Forty-seven respondents worked in centres with designated 'Hirschsprung's disease surgeons'. Forty respondents perform definitive Hirschsprung's disease surgery. In a well neonate with left-sided Hirschsprung's disease, 34 of 40 surgeons favour primary pull-through following bowel decompression with rectal washouts; 35 of 40 surgeons aim to perform definitive surgery at less than 3 months of age, with 17 favouring laparoscopic-assisted Soave-Boley and 15 favouring an open Duhamel pull-through. Of the 40 surgeons, 36 use a staged approach to right-sided/total colonic Hirschsprung's disease with 23 favouring a Duhamel or Long Duhamel pull-through.
The primary pull-through, using an open Duhamel or laparoscopic-assisted Soave-Boley technique, during the first 3 months of life, has become the operative strategy of choice in rectosigmoid Hirschsprung's disease in Britain. Marked variation in practice remains for right-sided Hirschsprung's disease.
先天性巨结肠的治疗方法不断发展。本次问卷调查旨在确定英国目前针对先天性巨结肠的手术治疗策略。
该调查问卷通过电子邮件发送给了所有英国儿科外科医生。最初的问题探讨了个人经验和地区服务提供情况。为进行先天性巨结肠根治手术的外科医生预留的其他问题涉及特定临床场景。
共向142名外科医生发送了调查问卷,收到85份回复。排除无效回复后,对来自21个中心的64份调查问卷进行了分析。47名受访者在设有“先天性巨结肠病外科医生”的中心工作。40名受访者进行先天性巨结肠根治手术。对于患有左侧先天性巨结肠的健康新生儿,40名外科医生中有34名倾向于在肠道减压及直肠冲洗后进行一期拖出术;40名外科医生中有35名旨在在3个月龄以内进行根治性手术,其中17名倾向于腹腔镜辅助Soave-Boley术式,15名倾向于开放性Duhamel拖出术。在这40名外科医生中,36名对右侧/全结肠型先天性巨结肠采用分期手术方法,其中23名倾向于Duhamel或Long Duhamel拖出术。
在出生后的前3个月内采用开放性Duhamel或腹腔镜辅助Soave-Boley技术进行一期拖出术,已成为英国直肠乙状结肠型先天性巨结肠的首选手术策略。对于右侧先天性巨结肠,实际操作仍存在显著差异。