Edwin Frank, Mamorare Hendrick, Brink Johann, Kinsley Robin
Walter Sisulu Pediatric Cardiac Center, Sunninghill Hospital, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2010 Nov;11(5):641-4. doi: 10.1510/icvts.2010.243832. Epub 2010 Aug 25.
In patients with transposition of the great arteries with intact ventricular septum (TGA-IVS), late presentation for surgical treatment is not uncommon. Earlier experience suggested an excess mortality for the primary arterial switch operation (ASO) when performed after the third week of life in such patients. The true age limit for the primary ASO, however, remains speculative. A best evidence topic was written to determine the safety of extending the age limit of the primary ASO for TGA-IVS beyond three weeks of age. Eight of 74 relevant papers constituted the best evidence to address the issue. Sufficient level II evidence was found to suggest that in experienced institutions in the current era, the ASO for TGA-IVS may be performed primarily in infants three to eight weeks of age with comparable early outcomes to younger patients. Kang et al. investigated 275 neonates (younger than 21 days) and 105 infants (age range 21-185 days) undergoing the primary ASO for TGA-IVS. They found no significant difference in terms of in-hospital mortality (5.5% vs. 3.8%) or need for mechanical left ventricular (LV) support (3.6% vs. 5.7%) between the younger and older groups, respectively. Of the younger group, 3.8% developed postoperative LV failure leading to death or mechanical LV support. All nine patients older than two months (age range 61-185 days) survived to discharge although two (aged 69 and 86 days) required mechanical LV support for postoperative LV failure. The postoperative course of the late ASO group, however, was significantly prolonged as reflected in the duration of postoperative ventilation (4.9 vs. 7.1 days, P=0.012) and length of postoperative stay (12.5 vs. 18.9 days, P=0.001). In the report of Sarris et al., 52 patients with TGA-IVS who were older than four weeks of age (36 were older than eight weeks) underwent a primary ASO with early mortality comparable with younger patients (2% vs. 3%, respectively). For infants between the ages of two and six months, the strength of the evidence favoring this management approach is limited by the small sample size of reported series and the increased requirement for mechanical circulatory support for postoperative LV failure.
在室间隔完整的大动脉转位(TGA-IVS)患者中,延迟进行手术治疗并不罕见。早期经验表明,此类患者在出生后第三周后进行一期动脉调转术(ASO)时死亡率过高。然而,一期ASO的真正年龄限制仍具有推测性。撰写了一篇最佳证据专题文章,以确定将TGA-IVS一期ASO的年龄限制延长至三周龄以上的安全性。74篇相关论文中的8篇构成了解决该问题的最佳证据。发现有足够的II级证据表明,在当代有经验的机构中,TGA-IVS的ASO主要可在3至8周龄的婴儿中进行,早期结果与较年轻患者相当。Kang等人调查了275例接受TGA-IVS一期ASO的新生儿(小于21天)和105例婴儿(年龄范围21 - 185天)。他们发现,较年轻组和较年长组在院内死亡率(分别为5.5%对3.8%)或需要机械左心室(LV)支持(分别为3.6%对5.7%)方面无显著差异。在较年轻组中,3.8%发生术后左心室衰竭,导致死亡或需要机械左心室支持。所有9例年龄超过两个月(年龄范围61 - 185天)的患者均存活至出院,尽管有2例(分别为69天和86天)因术后左心室衰竭需要机械左心室支持。然而,延迟ASO组的术后病程明显延长,术后通气时间(4.9天对7.1天,P = 0.012)和术后住院时间(12.5天对18.9天,P = 0.001)均有所体现。在Sarris等人的报告中,52例年龄超过四周(36例超过八周)的TGA-IVS患者接受了一期ASO,早期死亡率与较年轻患者相当(分别为2%对3%)。对于年龄在2至6个月之间的婴儿,支持这种管理方法的证据力度受到报告系列样本量小以及术后左心室衰竭对机械循环支持需求增加的限制。