Department of Pediatrics, Sørlandet Hospital, Arendal, Norway.
Am J Med Genet A. 2010 Sep;152A(9):2193-202. doi: 10.1002/ajmg.a.33605.
We previously reported that prenatal diagnosis of malformations is associated with increased parental psychological distress after birth compared to distress in parents with postnatal diagnosis. We have now extended our earlier study to include a long-term follow-up of mothers and fathers 9 years after birth. Psychological responses were measured by General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-28), State Anxiety Inventory (STAI-X1), and Impact of Event Scale (IES) in 118 mothers and 100 fathers of 124 children with malformations 0-7 days (T1), 6 weeks (T2), 6 months (T3), and 9 years postpartum (T4). At T4 we observed no significant differences in psychological responses comparing parents with and without prenatal foreknowledge of their child's malformation. At T4 30.2% and 27.8% of the parents reported clinically important psychological distress and clinically important state anxiety, respectively. Intrusive stress decreased from T1 to T3, but increased significantly from T3 to T4. At T4 25.6% of the parents reported severe intrusive stress, with a higher proportion among mothers than fathers (32.8% vs. 17.2%, P = 0.029). In the multivariate analysis, unemployment predicted clinically important psychological distress at T4, whereas, clinically important state anxiety at T4 was predicted by low educational level. This study shows that prenatal diagnosis is associated with significantly increased psychological distress in the acute postnatal phase. However, there was no long-term increase in psychological distress among parents with prenatal foreknowledge of their child's malformation. The significantly increased intrusive stress at 9-year follow-up might reflect long-term challenges related to having a child with a malformation.
我们之前报道过,与出生后诊断相比,产前诊断畸形会增加父母的产后心理困扰。我们现在将早期研究扩展到包括对畸形儿童的母亲和父亲在出生后 9 年的长期随访。在 T1(畸形儿童出生后 0-7 天)、T2(6 周)、T3(6 个月)和 T4(产后 9 年)时,使用一般健康问卷(GHQ-28)、状态焦虑量表(STAI-X1)和事件影响量表(IES)对 124 名儿童的 118 名母亲和 100 名父亲的心理反应进行了测量。在 T4 时,我们没有观察到有产前预知儿童畸形的父母与没有产前预知的父母之间的心理反应有显著差异。在 T4 时,分别有 30.2%和 27.8%的父母报告存在临床显著的心理困扰和临床显著的状态焦虑。侵入性压力从 T1 到 T3 下降,但从 T3 到 T4 显著增加。在 T4 时,有 25.6%的父母报告严重的侵入性压力,母亲的比例高于父亲(32.8%比 17.2%,P=0.029)。在多变量分析中,失业预测 T4 时存在临床显著的心理困扰,而 T4 时的临床显著状态焦虑则由低教育水平预测。本研究表明,产前诊断与产后急性阶段显著增加的心理困扰有关。然而,对于有产前预知的父母来说,并没有长期增加的心理困扰。9 年随访时侵入性压力显著增加可能反映了与生育畸形儿童相关的长期挑战。