College of Health Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Milwaukee, WI 53201, USA.
Clin J Pain. 2010 Oct;26(8):729-36. doi: 10.1097/AJP.0b013e3181f09713.
Laser phototherapy has been widely used to relieve pain for more than 30 years, but its efficacy remains controversial. To ascertain the overall effect of phototherapy on pain, we aggregated the literature and subjected the studies to statistical meta-analysis.
Relevant original studies were gathered from every available source and coded. Articles that met preestablished inclusion criteria were subjected to statistical meta-analysis, using Cohen's d statistic to determine treatment effect sizes.
Fifty-two effect sizes were computed from the 22 articles that met the inclusion criteria. The resulting overall mean effect size was highly significant; d = +0.84 (95% confidence interval = 0.44-1.23). The effect size remained significant even when a high outlying d value was conservatively excluded from the analysis; d = +0.66 (95% confidence interval = 0.46-0.86). The fail-safe number associated with the overall treatment effect, that is, the number of additional studies in which phototherapy has negative or no effect on pain needed to negate the overall large effect size of +0.84, was 348.
These findings warrant the conclusion that laser phototherapy effectively relieves pain of various etiologies; making it a valuable addition to contemporary pain management armamentarium.
激光光疗已广泛用于缓解疼痛超过 30 年,但疗效仍存在争议。为了确定光疗对疼痛的总体效果,我们汇集了文献并进行了统计荟萃分析。
从各种可用来源收集相关原始研究并进行编码。符合既定纳入标准的文章进行了统计荟萃分析,使用 Cohen's d 统计量来确定治疗效果大小。
从符合纳入标准的 22 篇文章中计算了 52 个效应量。总的平均效应量非常显著;d = +0.84(95%置信区间= 0.44-1.23)。即使从分析中保守地排除了一个高离群值 d 值,效应量仍然显著;d = +0.66(95%置信区间= 0.46-0.86)。与整体治疗效果相关的失效安全数,即需要多少额外的研究表明光疗对疼痛没有或没有负面效果才能否定整体的 +0.84 大效应量,为 348。
这些发现证明了激光光疗有效缓解各种病因引起的疼痛的结论;使其成为当代疼痛管理武器库的有价值的补充。