Wielandt Patricia M, Taylor Elizabeth
University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Rural Remote Health. 2010 Jul-Sep;10(3):1488. Epub 2010 Sep 17.
Currently Canadians living in rural communities tend to have a poorer health status than those living in urban settings. This is contributed to by the shortage of health professionals choosing work in rural and remote areas. Over the past decade there has been much research into the recruitment and retention of rural health professionals. However little has been done to identify the actual nature of rural practice and whether graduates have been adequately prepared for the diversity of rural work. The present study sought to identify the rewards and challenges of rural occupational therapy practice in western Canada. Participants' were also asked about their preparedness for rural practice after graduation, and specifically about the usefulness of course work and practical skills taught as undergraduates.
Participants were occupational therapists working in rural communities in the Canadian provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan. The quantitative approach employed a self-administered survey with closed- and open-ended questions. Data were entered into SPSS v14 (http://www.spss.com.au) for frequency data and percentages.
The participants (n = 59) worked mainly in full-time community healthcare positions with clients who had physical health issues. More than half worked in sole therapy positions. The average length of time in their current position was 5 years. Most participants reported that they were receiving informal professional support, with some receiving a formal support as well. Participants more frequently identified the rewards of rural practice (n = 214) than its challenges (n = 112). Perceived rewards included team work, autonomy, diversity and flexible work schedule, increased client contact, job satisfaction, experiences gained and the rural lifestyle. The most frequently mentioned challenges included staff shortages, the generalist nature of rural occupational therapy practice, excess time spent travelling, coping with inappropriate referrals and the need for more professional support. Regarding participants' perceptions about the course work and practical skills taught during their training that best prepared them for actual practice, some highlighted additional valuable resources such as actual hands-on experience during rural fieldwork placement, personal characteristics, working in an urban setting prior to embarking on a rural career, coming from a rural background and locating a mentor prior to working rurally. Some recommended increasing management and organisational skills content in the curriculum because these were considered essential skills for effective rural practice. The return of unanswered questionnaires by participants who did not consider themselves to be rural therapists because of access to online and telehealth resources suggests further research is warranted into the changing nature of rural practice.
Characteristics of current rural occupational therapy practice in western Canada were identified. Overall, rural occupational therapy practice appeared to be rewarding, and few had difficulty in accessing professional support. While on the whole the participants believed their training prepared them adequately for rural practice, the acquisition of increased management and organisational skills during training was seen as necessary to effectively manage their typically large and diverse caseloads. Participants' access to online and telehealth resources appears to have markedly changed the nature of rural practice and further research is recommended to determine the impact of such technologies.
目前,生活在农村社区的加拿大人健康状况往往比城市居民更差。这是由于选择在农村和偏远地区工作的卫生专业人员短缺所致。在过去十年中,对农村卫生专业人员的招聘和留用进行了大量研究。然而,对于农村医疗实践的实际性质以及毕业生是否为农村工作的多样性做好充分准备,却鲜有研究。本研究旨在确定加拿大西部农村职业治疗实践的回报与挑战。还询问了参与者毕业后对农村实践的准备情况,特别是本科阶段所学课程和实践技能的实用性。
参与者为在加拿大阿尔伯塔省和萨斯喀彻温省农村社区工作的职业治疗师。定量研究方法采用了包含封闭式和开放式问题的自填式调查问卷。数据录入SPSS v14(http://www.spss.com.au)以获取频率数据和百分比。
参与者(n = 59)主要从事全职社区医疗保健工作,服务对象为有身体健康问题的患者。超过半数担任单一治疗岗位。他们目前职位的平均时长为5年。大多数参与者报告称他们获得了非正式的专业支持,一些人还获得了正式支持。与挑战(n = 112)相比,参与者更常提到农村实践的回报(n = 214)。感知到的回报包括团队合作、自主权、多样性和灵活的工作时间表、与客户的接触增加、工作满意度、获得的经验以及农村生活方式。最常提到的挑战包括人员短缺、农村职业治疗实践的通才性质、花费在路途上的时间过多、应对不恰当的转诊以及需要更多专业支持。关于参与者对培训期间所学课程和实践技能的看法,这些技能使他们为实际实践做好了最佳准备,一些人强调了其他有价值的资源,如农村实地实习期间的实际动手经验、个人特质、在从事农村工作之前在城市环境中的工作经历、来自农村背景以及在农村工作之前找到一位导师。一些人建议在课程中增加管理和组织技能内容,因为这些被认为是有效开展农村实践的关键技能。那些因可获取在线和远程医疗资源而不认为自己是农村治疗师的参与者未回复问卷,这表明有必要进一步研究农村实践性质的变化。
确定了加拿大西部当前农村职业治疗实践的特点。总体而言,农村职业治疗实践似乎很有意义,很少有人在获得专业支持方面遇到困难。虽然总体上参与者认为他们的培训使他们为农村实践做好了充分准备,但他们认为在培训期间获得更多的管理和组织技能对于有效管理通常庞大且多样的病例负荷是必要的。参与者对在线和远程医疗资源的获取似乎显著改变了农村实践的性质,建议进一步研究以确定此类技术的影响。