Ahmad Y, Khandelwal S, Nicolson A M, Simms M H
Department of Vascular Surgery, Selly Oak Hospital, University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2011 Jan;93(1):44-8. doi: 10.1308/003588410X12771863937043. Epub 2010 Sep 22.
The UK Government has prioritised methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) screening and new operational guidance has instructed that all day-case surgical patients should be screened from April 2009. We sought to identify the number of MRSA-positive patients in the vascular day-case population over a 1-year period and to profile this cohort in terms of risk-factors for MRSA. We also sought to identify whether the new guidance from the Department of Health (DH) had resulted in increased screening rates.
Electronic records and laboratory culture results were prospectively consulted to identify whether patients had been screened and if MRSA had been isolated. Consideration was given to whether any patients had a delayed discharge or subsequent admission with an MRSA-related complication.
Six patients (2.1%) screened MRSA-positive (DH estimate 7%); five were previously known to be MRSA-positive, therefore only 0.36% patients were newly-identified as MRSA-positive. The proportion of patients screened increased from 35% to 72.5% after April 2009, in accordance with DH guidance. Successful decolonisation was proved in two patients (33.3%).
There is dispute with several of the key assumptions behind the DH's impact assessment justifying an expanded MRSA-screening policy. It is not cost-effective to screen all vascular day-case admissions. We recommend selective screening for patients previously identified as MRSA-positive, or considered high risk.
英国政府已将耐甲氧西林金黄色葡萄球菌(MRSA)筛查列为优先事项,新的操作指南指示,自2009年4月起应对所有日间手术患者进行筛查。我们试图确定在为期1年的血管日间手术人群中MRSA阳性患者的数量,并根据MRSA的风险因素对该队列进行分析。我们还试图确定卫生部(DH)的新指南是否导致筛查率提高。
前瞻性查阅电子记录和实验室培养结果,以确定患者是否接受了筛查以及是否分离出MRSA。考虑了是否有患者因MRSA相关并发症而延迟出院或随后入院。
6例患者(2.1%)筛查出MRSA阳性(卫生部估计为7%);5例之前已知为MRSA阳性,因此仅0.36%的患者新被确定为MRSA阳性。根据卫生部的指南,2009年4月后接受筛查的患者比例从35%增至72.5%。2例患者(33.3%)成功实现去定植。
对于卫生部支持扩大MRSA筛查政策的影响评估背后的几个关键假设存在争议。对所有血管日间手术入院患者进行筛查不具有成本效益。我们建议对先前确定为MRSA阳性或被认为是高危的患者进行选择性筛查。