Rickert Scott, Banuchi Victoria E, Germana Joan D, Stewart Michael G, April Max M
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York, NY 10021, USA.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Oct;136(10):988-92. doi: 10.1001/archoto.2010.162.
To observe the extent of nasal polyposis endoscopically in a cystic fibrosis population before the first surgical intervention and to grade the extent using a modified Malm scale, to observe patients prospectively and record the need for revision endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS), and to compare this among the individual polyp grading groupings.
Retrospective medical record review of data collected prospectively.
Tertiary care hospital.
Forty-nine consecutive patients with a clinical preoperative diagnosis of cystic fibrosis and sinusitis.
Using a modified Malm scale, the extent of polyps was prospectively graded into 3 groups before the first surgical intervention. The number of patients needing revision ESS and the mean time to revision ESS were compared among the 3 groups.
Forty-nine consecutive patients underwent ESS between 1992 and 2007. We used a 3-stage system for extent of polyposis: 16 patients were noted to have no polyps (grade A), 14 had mild polyposis (grade B), and 19 had extensive polyposis (grade C). During the study, 14 patients required revision surgery: 3 with mild polyps and 11 with extensive polyps. Mean time to revision surgery was 39.7 months for those with grade B and 23.8 months for those with grade C. In the overall statistical analysis, the rate of revision ESS was significantly different among the 3 groups (P < .001). In pairwise comparisons, there were significant differences between those with grades A and C (P < .001) and between those with grades B and C (P = .04) and a trend toward significance between those with grades A and B (P = .052). There were no complications from ESS.
Preoperative grading of nasal polyposis in patients with cystic fibrosis can help assess the future likelihood of revision ESS.
在内镜下观察囊性纤维化患者首次手术干预前鼻息肉的病变范围,并使用改良的马尔姆量表对病变范围进行分级,对患者进行前瞻性观察并记录再次内镜鼻窦手术(ESS)的需求,比较各息肉分级组之间的差异。
对前瞻性收集的数据进行回顾性病历审查。
三级医疗医院。
49例临床术前诊断为囊性纤维化和鼻窦炎的连续患者。
使用改良的马尔姆量表,在首次手术干预前将息肉病变范围前瞻性地分为3组。比较3组中需要再次进行ESS的患者数量和再次进行ESS的平均时间。
1992年至2007年间,49例连续患者接受了ESS。我们采用了一个3阶段系统来评估息肉病变范围:16例患者无息肉(A级),14例有轻度息肉(B级),19例有广泛息肉(C级)。在研究期间,14例患者需要再次手术:3例轻度息肉患者和11例广泛息肉患者。B级患者再次手术的平均时间为39.7个月,C级患者为23.8个月。在总体统计分析中,3组之间再次进行ESS的发生率有显著差异(P < .001)。在两两比较中,A级和C级患者之间有显著差异(P < .001),B级和C级患者之间有显著差异(P = .04),A级和B级患者之间有显著差异的趋势(P = .052)。ESS无并发症。
囊性纤维化患者鼻息肉的术前分级有助于评估未来再次进行ESS的可能性。