Volk Gerd Fabian, Pantel Mira, Guntinas-Lichius Orlando, Wittekindt Claus
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität, Lessingstraße 2, D-07743 Jena, Germany.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Oct;136(10):1015-9. doi: 10.1001/archoto.2010.161.
To identify objective criteria predicting the success of diode laser-assisted turbinoplasty.
Prospective before-and-after trial with follow-up of 8 weeks.
Outpatient department of a tertiary referral center.
Forty-one patients with nasal obstruction caused by hyperplastic inferior nasal turbinates.
Active anterior rhinomanometry with and without decongestion was used to assess the patients both before and after diode laser-assisted turbinate surgery. Surgery was performed under local anesthesia in "contact mode" using a continuous diode laser. In addition, a questionnaire assessed the subjective postoperative benefit.
Presurgical effect of topical decongestion was correlated with postoperative improvement of nasal airflow and patients' subjective satisfaction.
Turbinoplasty significantly improved the mean (SD) nasal airflow by 37.1% (52.4%) (95% confidence interval [CI], 20.6%-53.7%), from 509.8 (189.2) cm³/s (95% CI, 450.1-569.5) to 660.9 (285.4) cm³/s (95% CI, 570.8-751.0) (P < .001). There was no significant correlation between patients' subjective satisfaction and improvement of nasal airflow postoperatively (r(s) = -0.01; P = .93). There was a strong correlation between the presurgical effect of topical decongestion and the improvement of nasal airflow by surgery (r(s) = 0.42; P = .01). The correlation was even stronger when the absolute values were adjusted by the preoperative nasal airflow baseline (r(s) = 0.55; P = .01).
Rhinomanometry with topical decongestion has a high predictive value for the objective outcome of diode laser-assisted turbinoplasty. Thus, performing a rhinomanometry with topical decongestion and calculating the relative spread of decongestion can help to estimate the patients' benefit from diode laser-assisted turbinate surgery.
确定预测二极管激光辅助下鼻甲成形术成功的客观标准。
前瞻性前后对照试验,随访8周。
三级转诊中心门诊部。
41例因下鼻甲增生导致鼻塞的患者。
在二极管激光辅助下鼻甲手术前后,使用主动前鼻测压法(有无减充血剂)对患者进行评估。手术在局部麻醉下采用连续二极管激光以“接触模式”进行。此外,通过问卷调查评估术后主观获益情况。
局部减充血剂的术前效果与术后鼻气流改善情况及患者主观满意度的相关性。
下鼻甲成形术使平均(标准差)鼻气流显著改善37.1%(52.4%)(95%置信区间[CI],20.6%-53.7%),从509.8(189.2)cm³/s(95%CI,450.1-569.5)增至660.9(285.4)cm³/s(95%CI,570.8-751.0)(P<.001)。患者主观满意度与术后鼻气流改善之间无显著相关性(斯皮尔曼等级相关系数r(s)=-0.01;P=.93)。局部减充血剂的术前效果与手术引起的鼻气流改善之间存在强相关性(r(s)=0.42;P=.01)。当通过术前鼻气流基线调整绝对值时,相关性更强(r(s)=0.55;P=.01)。
局部减充血剂鼻测压法对二极管激光辅助下鼻甲成形术的客观结果具有较高的预测价值。因此,进行局部减充血剂鼻测压并计算减充血剂的相对变化幅度有助于评估患者从二极管激光辅助下鼻甲手术中获得的益处。