Kleine-Tebbe J, Herold D A
Allergie- u. Asthma-Zentrum Westend, Praxis Hanf, Herold & Kleine-Tebbe, Spandauer Damm 130, Haus 9, 14050, Berlin.
Hautarzt. 2010 Nov;61(11):961-6. doi: 10.1007/s00105-010-1969-9.
Inappropriate test methods are increasingly utilized to diagnose allergy. They fall into two categories: I. Tests with obscure theoretical basis, missing validity and lacking reproducibility, such as bioresonance, electroacupuncture, applied kinesiology and the ALCAT-test. These methods lack both the technical and clinical validation needed to justify their use. II. Tests with real data, but misleading interpretation: Detection of IgG or IgG4-antibodies or lymphocyte proliferation tests to foods do not allow to separate healthy from diseased subjects, neither in case of food intolerance, allergy or other diagnoses. The absence of diagnostic specificity induces many false positive findings in healthy subjects. As a result unjustified diets might limit quality of life and lead to malnutrition. Proliferation of lymphocytes in response to foods can show elevated rates in patients with allergies. These values do not allow individual diagnosis of hypersensitivity due to their broad variation. Successful internet marketing, infiltration of academic programs and superficial reporting by the media promote the popularity of unqualified diagnostic tests; also in allergy. Therefore, critical observation and quick analysis of and clear comments to unqualified methods by the scientific medical societies are more important than ever.
不恰当的检测方法越来越多地被用于诊断过敏。它们可分为两类:一、理论基础模糊、缺乏有效性和可重复性的检测方法,如生物共振、电针疗法、应用运动机能学和ALCAT检测。这些方法缺乏证明其使用合理性所需的技术和临床验证。二、有实际数据但解读具有误导性的检测方法:检测食物的IgG或IgG4抗体或淋巴细胞增殖试验,无论是在食物不耐受、过敏或其他诊断情况下,都无法区分健康人和患病者。缺乏诊断特异性会在健康受试者中导致许多假阳性结果。结果,不合理的饮食可能会限制生活质量并导致营养不良。过敏患者对食物产生反应的淋巴细胞增殖率可能会升高。由于这些值变化范围广泛,因此无法用于个体超敏反应的诊断。成功的网络营销、学术项目的渗透以及媒体的表面报道促进了不合格诊断检测方法的普及;在过敏领域也是如此。因此,科学医学协会对不合格方法进行批判性观察、快速分析和清晰评论比以往任何时候都更加重要。