Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Alabama, Birmingham, 35249, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2010 Nov;195(5):1137-41. doi: 10.2214/AJR.09.3968.
The purpose of the study was to determine whether a difference in patient preference exists between iohexol (Omnipaque) and diatrizoate sodium (Gastroview) as oral contrast medium for abdominal-pelvic CT. A secondary objective was to evaluate whether there are significant differences in bowel opacification and adverse effect profile for the two agents.
From August 2007 through March 2009, 300 patients were enrolled in this prospective study after informed consent was obtained. Eligible patients were identified from those scheduled for outpatient abdominal-pelvic CT. Subjects were randomly assigned to receive one of two oral contrast agents in a double-blinded fashion. Subjects graded the taste using a 5-point scale, and data regarding demographics, total volume, and adverse effects were collected. A direct comparison of 30 mL of each of the two diluted agents in randomized order was then performed. CT images were graded for bowel opacification by two blinded abdominal radiologists.
Of 287 subjects who expressed a preference, 233 patients (81%) preferred dilute iohexol compared with 54 patients (19%) who preferred dilute diatrizoate sodium (p < 0.001). Ten patients had no preference, and three patients did not complete the taste comparison study. No difference in bowel opacification was identified between the oral contrast agents (p = 0.27), nor was there a significant difference in adverse effects (p = 0.352).
Patents preferred dilute iohexol over dilute diatrizoate sodium for oral contrast for abdominal-pelvic CT. There was no significant difference in bowel opacification or adverse effect profile.
本研究旨在确定在腹部-盆腔 CT 中,口服对比剂碘海醇(欧乃派克)和泛影酸钠(胃影葡胺)的患者偏好是否存在差异。次要目的是评估两种药物在肠道显影和不良事件特征方面是否存在显著差异。
本前瞻性研究于 2007 年 8 月至 2009 年 3 月期间进行,共纳入 300 例知情同意的患者。从计划行门诊腹部-盆腔 CT 的患者中筛选出符合条件的患者。采用双盲法将患者随机分配至两种口服对比剂组。患者使用 5 分制对口感进行评分,并收集人口统计学、总容积和不良反应等数据。然后,以随机顺序比较两种稀释剂各 30ml。由两位盲法腹部放射科医生对肠道显影进行 CT 图像评分。
在表达偏好的 287 例患者中,233 例(81%)患者更喜欢稀释后的碘海醇,而 54 例(19%)患者更喜欢稀释后的泛影酸钠(p < 0.001)。10 例患者无偏好,3 例患者未完成口感比较研究。两种口服对比剂的肠道显影无显著差异(p = 0.27),不良反应也无显著差异(p = 0.352)。
与稀释后的泛影酸钠相比,患者更倾向于使用稀释后的碘海醇作为腹部-盆腔 CT 的口服对比剂。肠道显影和不良反应特征无显著差异。