Guberman N
Sante Ment Que. 1990 May;15(1):62-84.
This article analyzes Québec mental health policy from a feminist point of view. The critique focuses on the decyphering of three tacit premises that the author describes as wanting. On the base of these premises, the author argues that the policy avoids differences in sex and in gender role and their impact on mental health/disorders, that it belongs to a "naturalist" trend that wants to benefit families through the social integration of psychiatrized patients, and that it offers a scuttled partnership with women's groups. The author concludes by pointing out the policy's limits and dangers for women and women's groups, and by raising the issue of the relationship feminist services maintain with the State.
本文从女性主义视角分析了魁北克的心理健康政策。批评集中在对三个隐含前提的解读上，作者认为这些前提存在问题。基于这些前提，作者认为该政策回避了性别差异及其对心理健康/疾病的影响，它属于一种“自然主义”趋势，试图通过将患有精神疾病的患者社会融入来使家庭受益，并且它与女性团体的合作半途而废。作者最后指出了该政策对女性和女性团体的局限性与危险性，并提出了女性主义服务机构与国家之间关系的问题。
