Konter Erkut
Dokuz Eylül University, Buca Educational Faculty, Buca, Izmir, Turkey.
Coll Antropol. 2010 Sep;34(3):1001-8.
The purpose of this study was to analyze the leadership power perception of amateur and professional soccer coaches and players according to their belief in good luck or not. Data collected from 165 male soccer coaches and 870 male soccer players including professionals and amateurs. The coaches had a mean age of 40.24 years (SD = 8.40) and had been coaching for an average of 8.56 years (SD = 6.75). The players had a mean age of 18.40 years (SD = 4.00) and had been playing soccer for an average of 6.00 years (SD = 4.15) with license. Adapted Turkish version of Power in Soccer Questionnaire-Other (PSQ-O for soccer players), Power in Soccer Questionnaire-Self (PSQ-S for coaches) and an information form were used for the data collection. Cronbach Reliability Alphas of PSQ-O and PSQ-S range between 0.60 and 0.84. Players' and coaches' data were analyzed by Kruskal-Wallis and Mann Whitney Tests. Analysis of PSQ-O revealed significant differences related to Coersive Power-CP [chi2 (3) = 8.46, p < 0.037], Referent Power-RP [chi2 (3) = 14.84, p < 0.002] and Expert Power-EP [chi2 (3) = 7.63, p < 0.054], and no significant differences related to Legitimate Power-LP (p > 0.05). Results of PSQ-O and PSQ-S indicated complex relationships related to belief in good luck or not. Overall, there are differences between coaches' and players'perception of CP, LP and EP related to belief in good luck or not. The only similarity appears to be in perception of RP. However, there is lack of research to make more certain conclusions. Future researchers should also take into consideration gender, sport experience, age, taking responsibility, self-confidence, attributions, expectations, superstitions, emotions, perception of achievement etc.
本研究的目的是根据业余和职业足球教练及球员对好运的信念,分析他们对领导权力的认知。数据收集自165名男性足球教练和870名男性足球运动员,包括职业球员和业余球员。教练的平均年龄为40.24岁(标准差=8.40),平均执教年限为8.56年(标准差=6.75)。球员的平均年龄为18.40岁(标准差=4.00),平均有6.00年(标准差=4.15)的持证踢球经历。采用改编后的土耳其语版《足球中的权力问卷 - 他人版》(用于球员的PSQ - O)、《足球中的权力问卷 - 自我版》(用于教练的PSQ - S)和一份信息表进行数据收集。PSQ - O和PSQ - S的克朗巴赫信度系数在0.60至0.84之间。球员和教练的数据通过克鲁斯卡尔 - 沃利斯检验和曼 - 惠特尼检验进行分析。对PSQ - O的分析显示,在强制权力 - CP[卡方(3)=8.46,p<0.037]、参照权力 - RP[卡方(3)=14.84,p<0.002]和专家权力 - EP[卡方(3)=7.63,p<0.054]方面存在显著差异,而在合法权力 - LP方面无显著差异(p>0.05)。PSQ - O和PSQ - S的结果表明,与对好运的信念存在复杂关系。总体而言,教练和球员在与对好运的信念相关的CP、LP和EP认知上存在差异。唯一的相似之处似乎在于对RP的认知。然而,缺乏研究以得出更确定的结论。未来的研究人员还应考虑性别、运动经历、年龄、承担责任、自信心、归因、期望、迷信、情绪、成就认知等因素。