Naicker S, Eastwood J B, Plange-Rhule J, Tutt R C
Division of Nephrology, Department of Internal Medicine, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Clin Nephrol. 2010 Nov;74 Suppl 1:S129-33. doi: 10.5414/cnp74s129.
The paper assesses the lack of healthcare workers, the consequences, and possible solutions.
Review of existing literature and global health reports.
The 47 countries of sub-Saharan Africa have a critical shortage of healthcare workers, the deficit amounting to 2.4 million doctors and nurses. There are 2 doctors and 11 nursing/midwifery personnel per 10,000 population, compared with 19 doctors and 49 nursing/midwifery personnel per 10,000 for the Americas, and 32 doctors and 78 nursing/midwifery personnel per 10,000 for Europe. And, whereas there are 28 doctors and 87 nurses/midwifery personnel per 10,000 in high income regions of the world, there are only 5 doctors and 11 nurses/ midwifery personnel per 10,000 in low income regions. The shortage of nephrologists in Africa, and especially sub-Saharan Africa, remains a critical issue, with many countries having < 1 nephrologist per million population; some have no nephrologists at all. The USA, UK, Canada and Australia have benefitted considerably from the migration of nurses and doctors over the past half century. Opportunities for training as well as employment have attracted doctors from many countries to these developed countries. Since 2006, new legislation in the UK has limited the inflow of health workers. Developing countries are also beginning to take steps to mitigate the problem of health worker loss and are developing strategies to both train increasing numbers of different cadres of healthcare worker and also to retain those already working in these countries.
The forces of globalization are tending to increase the worldwide movement of all types of professionals, including those working in health care. It is this lack of health workers in developing countries that has been such a major constraint in limiting progress on initiatives such as the HIV "3 by 5" and Millennium Development Goals. More specifically, lack of resources, both human and financial, in developing countries has hampered nephrology programs both in the detection and prevention of chronic kidney disease and in the ability of doctors, nurses and other nephrological personnel to provide acute/chronic dialysis and transplantation.
本文评估医疗工作者短缺的情况、后果及可能的解决办法。
对现有文献及全球健康报告进行综述。
撒哈拉以南非洲的47个国家严重缺乏医疗工作者,短缺数量达240万医生和护士。每万人口中有2名医生和11名护理/助产人员,相比之下,美洲每万人口中有19名医生和49名护理/助产人员,欧洲每万人口中有32名医生和78名护理/助产人员。而且,世界高收入地区每万人口中有28名医生和87名护士/助产人员,而低收入地区每万人口中仅有5名医生和11名护士/助产人员。非洲,尤其是撒哈拉以南非洲,肾病学家短缺仍是一个关键问题,许多国家每百万人口中肾病学家不足1名;有些国家根本没有肾病学家。在过去半个世纪里,美国、英国、加拿大和澳大利亚从护士和医生的移民中受益匪浅。培训及就业机会吸引了许多国家的医生前往这些发达国家。自2006年以来,英国的新立法限制了卫生工作者的流入。发展中国家也开始采取措施缓解卫生工作者流失问题,并制定战略,既要培养越来越多不同类别的医疗工作者,也要留住那些已在这些国家工作的人员。
全球化趋势促使包括医疗保健领域专业人员在内的各类专业人员在全球范围内流动。发展中国家医疗工作者的短缺是限制诸如艾滋病“3年内治疗500万人”倡议和千年发展目标等举措取得进展的一个主要制约因素。更具体地说,发展中国家人力和财力资源的匮乏阻碍了肾病项目,无论是在慢性肾病的检测和预防方面,还是在医生、护士及其他肾病专业人员提供急性/慢性透析和移植的能力方面。