Haddiya Intissar, Ramdani Sara, Chtioui Wijdane, Sidi Aly Abdellatif, Mah Sidi Mohamed, Niang Abdou, Azzabi Awatef, Elmowafy Ahmed Yahia, Mahamat Maimouna, Akagah Ademba Angélique, Nzeyimana Sylvain Pierre, Zalba Mahamat Abderraman G
Department of Nephrology, Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy of Oujda, University Mohammed Premier, Oujda, Morocco.
Laboratory of Epidemiology, Clinical Research and Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy of Oujda, University Mohammed Premier, Oujda, Morocco.
Front Health Serv. 2025 May 14;5:1523196. doi: 10.3389/frhs.2025.1523196. eCollection 2025.
Social responsibility (SR) in health is of paramount importance in the development of health systems. It is, therefore, frequently presented as one of the solutions for healthcare improvement in most developed countries. In addition, SR in health has been the subject of several publications in the West and Asia. However, the absence of African data on this subject motivated us to carry out this study which aimed to assess SR of African public hospitals in terms of kidney disease management, and to explore the factors that influence it based on the perceptions of patients and nephrologists, and to suggest concrete solutions to improve it.
Our study included participants, nephrologists and patients, of public hospitals in ten African countries. Two structured questionnaires were developed to measure the perception of patients and nephrologists regarding the hospital's performance based on four dimensions: Quality of service, pertinence of care, accessibility and professional ethics. Statistical analysis of the survey data included the Student's -test, the Chi-square test, univariate and multivariate logistic regression methods on several levels, in order to examine the factors influencing the patients' and nephrologists' evaluation of hospital SR.
Only 26.95% of the included patients believed that their hospitals were socially responsible. In fact, the general conditions of the hospitals and the accessibility of care (waiting times, overall cost, unavailability of treatments) were generally perceived to be unsatisfactory. Also, patients generally believed that receiving treatment regardless of their ability to pay was not always possible.As for doctors, 60% of the participants considered their hospitals not socially responsible. They had raised, in addition to the social determinants of health, a number of factors hindering SR of African hospitals, such as the lack of health professionals and brain drain.Finally, nephrologists suggested solutions, mainly directed at hospital managers, encompassing the following three components: Recruitment and training of human resources, leadership and governance, as well as strengthening of infrastructures and logistics.
Our study highlighted the crucial role of hospital governance and stakeholder involvement in improving SR and care delivery. Participants' perceptions and concerns inform health authorities about managing kidney disease in African hospitals.
健康领域的社会责任(SR)在卫生系统发展中至关重要。因此,在大多数发达国家,它常被视为改善医疗保健的解决方案之一。此外,健康领域的社会责任一直是西方和亚洲一些出版物的主题。然而,由于缺乏非洲关于这一主题的数据,我们开展了这项研究,旨在评估非洲公立医院在肾病管理方面的社会责任,并根据患者和肾病专家的看法探索影响其的因素,并提出具体的改进措施。
我们的研究纳入了十个非洲国家公立医院的参与者、肾病专家和患者。我们编制了两份结构化问卷,以基于服务质量、护理相关性、可及性和职业道德这四个维度来衡量患者和肾病专家对医院绩效的看法。对调查数据的统计分析包括学生t检验、卡方检验、多个层面的单变量和多变量逻辑回归方法,以研究影响患者和肾病专家对医院社会责任评价的因素。
纳入研究的患者中只有26.95%认为他们的医院具有社会责任感。事实上,医院的总体状况和护理可及性(等待时间、总体费用、治疗不可用)普遍被认为不尽人意。此外,患者普遍认为并非总能无论支付能力如何都能接受治疗。至于医生,60%的参与者认为他们的医院不具有社会责任感。除了健康的社会决定因素外,他们还提出了一些阻碍非洲医院履行社会责任的因素,如卫生专业人员短缺和人才外流。最后,肾病专家提出了主要针对医院管理人员的解决方案,包括以下三个方面:人力资源的招聘和培训、领导与治理以及基础设施和后勤的加强。
我们的研究强调了医院治理和利益相关者参与在改善社会责任和医疗服务提供方面的关键作用。参与者的看法和关切为卫生当局管理非洲医院的肾病提供了参考。