University of British Columbia, School of Nursing, Canada.
Nurse Educ Today. 2011 Aug;31(6):601-6. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2010.10.015. Epub 2010 Nov 6.
The judicious selection of nursing school applicants is important, and universities are increasingly incorporating non-academic criteria into their admission processes. We undertook a retrospective, correlational study of the predictive utility of an admissions process for nursing students' "in-program" success. The sample consisted of all 249 students admitted to a Canadian accelerated baccalaureate nursing program over a four-year study period. The students' arithmetic mean grade for six nursing courses (both theoretical and clinical) and their final grade point average (GPA) at graduation were the outcome measures of student success. The predictor variables included the applicants' demographic characteristics (e.g., age, gender, ethnic minority status, and previous educational attainment), their supplemental application materials and interview scores (assessing non-academic criteria), and their admission GPA. Linear regression was conducted on the outcome measures to determine whether the selection tools added information over that obtained through the use of admission GPA in predicting success. Although their admission GPAs were consistently predictive of the students' success, neither the supplemental application nor the interview scores had predictive utility. The variables consistently predictive of student success were age, ethnic minority status, and admission GPA, accounting for 26% of the variance in the selected nursing grades and 36% of the variance in GPA at graduation. The results provided little evidence to justify using the selective admissions tools.
明智地选择护理学校的申请人很重要,各大学越来越多地将非学术标准纳入其招生流程。我们对护理学生“在校内”成功的招生流程的预测实用性进行了回顾性相关研究。该样本包括在四年研究期间被加拿大加速护理学士学位课程录取的所有 249 名学生。学生在六门护理课程(理论和临床)中的算术平均成绩和他们毕业时的最终平均绩点(GPA)是学生成功的衡量标准。预测变量包括申请人的人口统计学特征(例如年龄、性别、少数族裔地位和以前的教育程度)、他们的补充申请材料和面试成绩(评估非学术标准)以及他们的入学 GPA。对结果指标进行线性回归,以确定选择工具是否在预测成功方面提供了除使用入学 GPA 之外的信息。尽管他们的入学 GPA 一直是学生成功的预测指标,但补充申请或面试成绩均没有预测实用性。始终能预测学生成功的变量是年龄、少数族裔地位和入学 GPA,它们分别占所选护理成绩的 26%和毕业时 GPA 的 36%。结果几乎没有提供证据来证明使用选择性招生工具是合理的。