Department of Computer Science, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
BMC Cardiovasc Disord. 2010 Nov 10;10:56. doi: 10.1186/1471-2261-10-56.
Aortic calcification is a major risk factor for death from cardiovascular disease. We investigated the relationship between mortality and the composite markers of number, size, morphology and distribution of calcified plaques in the lumbar aorta.
308 postmenopausal women aged 48-76 were followed for 8.3 ± 0.3 years, with deaths related to cardiovascular disease, cancer, or other causes being recorded. From lumbar X-rays at baseline the number (NCD), size, morphology and distribution of aortic calcification lesions were scored and combined into one Morphological Atherosclerotic Calcification Distribution (MACD) index. The hazard ratio for mortality was calculated for the MACD and for three other commonly used predictors: the EU SCORE card, the Framingham Coronary Heart Disease Risk Score (Framingham score), and the gold standard Aortic Calcification Severity score (AC24) developed from the Framingham Heart Study cohorts.
All four scoring systems showed increasing age, smoking, and raised triglyceride levels were the main predictors of mortality after adjustment for all other metabolic and physical parameters. The SCORE card and the Framingham score resulted in a mortality hazard ratio increase per standard deviation (HR/SD) of 1.8 (1.51-2.13) and 2.6 (1.87-3.71), respectively. Of the morphological x-ray based measures, NCD revealed a HR/SD >2 adjusted for SCORE/Framingham. The MACD index scoring the distribution, size, morphology and number of lesions revealed the best predictive power for identification of patients at risk of mortality, with a hazard ratio of 15.6 (p < 0.001) for the 10% at greatest risk of death.
This study shows that it is not just the extent of aortic calcification that predicts risk of mortality, but also the distribution, shape and size of calcified lesions. The MACD index may provide a more sensitive predictor of mortality from aortic calcification than the commonly used AC24 and SCORE/Framingham point card systems.
主动脉钙化是心血管疾病死亡的主要危险因素。我们研究了腰椎主动脉钙化斑块数量、大小、形态和分布的综合标志物与死亡率之间的关系。
对 308 名年龄在 48-76 岁之间的绝经后女性进行了 8.3±0.3 年的随访,记录了与心血管疾病、癌症或其他原因相关的死亡。从基线腰椎 X 射线中,对主动脉钙化病变的数量(NCD)、大小、形态和分布进行评分,并将其组合成一个形态动脉粥样硬化钙化分布(MACD)指数。计算 MACD 与三种常用预测因子(EU SCORE 卡、Framingham 冠心病风险评分(Framingham 评分)和Framingham 心脏研究队列开发的金标准主动脉钙化严重程度评分(AC24))的死亡率风险比。
在调整所有其他代谢和物理参数后,所有四个评分系统均显示年龄增长、吸烟和甘油三酯水平升高是死亡率的主要预测因素。SCORE 卡和Framingham 评分导致每标准差死亡率的危险比(HR/SD)分别增加 1.8(1.51-2.13)和 2.6(1.87-3.71)。在形态学 X 射线测量中,NCD 在调整 SCORE/Framingham 后显示 HR/SD>2。分布、大小、形态和病变数量的 MACD 指数评分显示出对识别死亡风险患者的最佳预测能力,风险比为 15.6(p<0.001),即 10%的患者死亡风险最高。
本研究表明,预测死亡率的不仅仅是主动脉钙化的程度,还有钙化病变的分布、形状和大小。MACD 指数可能比常用的 AC24 和 SCORE/Framingham 点卡系统更能敏感地预测主动脉钙化的死亡率。