Center for Subjectivity Research, Department of Media, Cognition and Communication, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Conscious Cogn. 2011 Mar;20(1):141-8. doi: 10.1016/j.concog.2010.10.011. Epub 2010 Nov 12.
The 'self' is increasingly used as a variable in cognitive experiments and correlated with activity in particular areas in the brain. At first glance, this seems to transform the self from an ephemeral theoretical entity to something concrete and measurable. However, the transformation is by no means unproblematic. We trace the development of two important experimental paradigms in the study of the self, self-face recognition and the adjective self ascription task. We show how the experimental instrumentalization has gone hand in hand with a simplification of the self-concept, and how more conceptual and theoretical reflections on the structure, function and nature of self have either disappeared altogether or receded into the background. We argue that this development impedes and complicates the interdisciplinary study of self.
“自我”在认知实验中越来越多地被用作变量,并与大脑特定区域的活动相关联。乍一看,这似乎将自我从一个短暂的理论实体转变为具体和可测量的东西。然而,这种转变绝非没有问题。我们追踪了自我研究中两个重要实验范式的发展,即自我面孔识别和形容词自我归因任务。我们展示了实验工具化是如何与自我概念的简化齐头并进的,以及对自我的结构、功能和本质的更多概念性和理论性思考是如何完全消失或退居幕后的。我们认为,这种发展阻碍和复杂化了自我的跨学科研究。