Department of Legal Medicine, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
Dent Traumatol. 2010 Dec;26(6):459-65. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-9657.2010.00935.x.
Dental injuries represent the most common claims against the anaesthesiologist. Dental lesions are frequent complications of oro-tracheal intubation and major causal factors are (i) poor dentition, (ii) aggressive laryngoscopy, (iii) insufficient anaesthesia and curarization, (iv) emergency interventions and (v) lack of experience by the anaesthesiologist.
We conducted a retrospective analysis of 83 cases of dental lesions occurring during elective, emergent and urgent surgery requiring general anaesthesia with tracheal tube placement in the years between 2000 and 2008. Preoperative evaluation of dental status was obtained from the anaesthesiology chart, filled by an experienced anaesthesiologist during the preoperative visit. Anaesthesiological records were inspected by physicians of Legal Medicine Department with the aim to attribute responsibility for the damage and manage potential reimbursements. Costs related to the required dental repair were also noted.
Eighty-three patients of a total of 60.000 surgical procedures (no day surgery) under general anaesthesia were affected by dental lesions (0.13%). Seventy-five per cent of lesions occurred during intubation manoeuvres for elective major surgery, 15% occurred at tracheal intubation for minor surgery and 10% were related to emergency surgery. Teeth avulsions accounted for 50% of lesions, followed by damage to crowns and bridges (14%), luxations and fractures (>15%).
The overall incidence of dental injury in our retrospective study was 1.38 per 1000 anaesthetics, which is slightly higher than those reported by some and lower with respect to others. Avulsion of a permanent tooth occurred in patients who were affected by severe mobility of native teeth while undergoing surgery. Even though the majority of anaesthesiologists were trained enough in the use of airway devices and aware of the potential damage while using excessive forces, some unexpected difficulties may have led to lesions. It is known that damage to teeth can occur even in the absence of negligence.
牙齿损伤是麻醉医师最常见的索赔原因。牙齿损伤是经口气管插管的常见并发症,主要原因有:(i)牙齿不良,(ii)喉镜检查激进,(iii)麻醉和肌松不足,(iv)紧急干预,以及(v)麻醉医师经验不足。
我们对 2000 年至 2008 年期间因全身麻醉下气管插管而进行的择期、紧急和紧急手术中发生的 83 例牙齿损伤病例进行了回顾性分析。术前评估牙齿状况是从麻醉图表中获得的,由经验丰富的麻醉医师在术前访视期间填写。法医部门的医生检查了麻醉记录,目的是确定损害责任并管理潜在的赔偿。还记录了与所需牙齿修复相关的费用。
在总共 60000 例全身麻醉手术(无日间手术)中,83 例患者发生牙齿损伤(0.13%)。75%的损伤发生在择期大手术的插管操作期间,15%发生在小手术的气管插管期间,10%与急诊手术有关。牙齿脱位占损伤的 50%,其次是牙冠和桥损伤(14%)、脱位和骨折(>15%)。
我们的回顾性研究中牙齿损伤的总发生率为每 1000 例麻醉 1.38 例,略高于一些报道,但低于其他报道。在手术过程中,患有严重原生牙齿活动度的患者发生了恒牙脱位。尽管大多数麻醉医师在使用气道设备方面受过足够的训练,并在使用过度力量时意识到潜在的损伤,但一些意外的困难可能导致了损伤。众所周知,即使没有疏忽,牙齿也可能受损。