Prulière-Escabasse Virginie, Coste Andre, Chauvin Pierre, Fauroux Brigitte, Tamalet Aline, Garabedian Erea-Noel, Escudier Estelle, Roger Gilles
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Hôpital Intercommunal de Créteil, 94000 Créteil CEDEX, France.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Nov;136(11):1121-6. doi: 10.1001/archoto.2010.183.
To analyze otologic features in patients with primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) aged 0 to 18 years and to evaluate the correlation between ultrastructural defects and severity of otologic features.
Retrospective study.
Pediatric referral center.
Fifty-eight patients with PCD were evaluated in the following 4 age intervals: group 1, preschool (≤ 5 years [n = 47]); group 2, school (6-11 years [n = 50]); group 3, teenagers (12-17 years [n = 34]); and group 4, young adults (≥ 18 years; 27 years for the oldest [n = 10]). Follow-up was 2 to 6 years in each age group; 26 patients had total follow-up of more than 12 years. Ultrastructural defects occurred in the outer dynein arm (n = 33), the inner dynein arm (n = 13), and the central complex (n = 11). One patient had typical Kartagener syndrome with typical PCD features but normal ciliary ultrastructure.
Frequency of acute otitis media, otitis media with effusion, otorrhea, chronic otitis media, hearing loss, and middle ear surgery and type of antibiotic regimen according to age and type of defect.
Recurrent acute otitis media decreased from group 1 (32 of 47 [68%]) to group 4 (0 of 10 [0%]) (P < .001). Otitis media with effusion was more severe in groups 1 through 3 than in group 4 (P = .02). Otorrhea decreased in group 4: 30% vs 80% (3 of 10 vs 36 of 41) in the other groups (P < .001). Half of the patients with tympanostomy tubes eventually had tympanic perforation. Hearing loss was moderate in groups 1 through 3 and mild in group 4. Continuous antibiotic therapy could be slightly reduced only in group 4. Central complex defect was a significant marker of severity for all these criteria.
Despite continuous antibiotic therapy, the middle ear condition in PCD remained severe throughout childhood, with improvement only after age 18 years. Armstrong grommet placement did not improve the middle ear condition. Central complex defect is a marker of severity.
分析0至18岁原发性纤毛运动障碍(PCD)患者的耳科特征,并评估超微结构缺陷与耳科特征严重程度之间的相关性。
回顾性研究。
儿科转诊中心。
58例PCD患者按以下4个年龄区间进行评估:第1组,学龄前儿童(≤5岁[n = 47]);第2组,学龄儿童(6 - 11岁[n = 50]);第3组,青少年(12 - 17岁[n = 34]);第4组,青年成人(≥18岁;最大27岁[n = 10])。每个年龄组的随访时间为2至6年;26例患者的总随访时间超过12年。超微结构缺陷发生在外动力臂(n = 33)、内动力臂(n = 13)和中央复合体(n = 11)。1例患者患有典型的卡塔格内综合征,具有典型的PCD特征,但纤毛超微结构正常。
根据年龄和缺陷类型,统计急性中耳炎、中耳积液、耳漏、慢性中耳炎、听力损失、中耳手术的发生率以及抗生素治疗方案的类型。
复发性急性中耳炎从第1组(47例中的32例[68%])降至第4组(10例中的0例[0%])(P <.001)。第1至3组的中耳积液比第4组更严重(P =.02)。第4组的耳漏减少:30% 对比其他组的80%(10例中的3例对比41例中的36例)(P <.001)。一半的鼓膜置管患者最终出现鼓膜穿孔。第1至3组的听力损失为中度,第4组为轻度。仅在第4组中,持续抗生素治疗可略有减少。中央复合体缺陷是所有这些标准严重程度的重要标志。
尽管进行了持续的抗生素治疗,但PCD患者的中耳状况在整个儿童期仍然严重,仅在18岁以后有所改善。阿姆斯特朗鼓膜置管并未改善中耳状况。中央复合体缺陷是严重程度的标志。