Meyerrose Berit, Conrad Susann, Fishman Liat, Langer Thomas, Weikert Beate, Weinbrenner Susanne
Ärztliches Zentrum für Qualität in der Medizin (ÄZQ), Berlin.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2010;104(7):540-6. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2010.07.006. Epub 2010 Aug 21.
For seven years the German National Disease Management Guidelines Programme (NDMG Programme) has been supported by its funding bodies: the German Medical Association, the National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians, and the Association of Scientific Medical Societies. The objectives of the NDMG Programme are to develop and to implement comprehensive national clinical guidelines for the management of selected illnesses. Key points of NDMG methodology are the strict adherence to the principles of evidence-based medicine as well as the avoidance of contradictory recommendations by means of neutrally facilitated consensus rounds. Despite the standardised NDMG methodology each guideline has individual structural and content features that make it unique. For example, the complex illness type 2 diabetes is presented in topic- and problem-oriented NDMG modules. For unipolar depression, the NDMG was simultaneously developed as a S3 guideline. Furthermore each NDMG group was faced with its own content-based challenges. For instance, in the case of the NDMG Low-back Pain the guideline group intensely and controversially discussed the definition of unspecific low-back pain. The NDMG Asthma does not solely address adults, but also children and adolescents, and the NDMG Heart Failure for the first time covers other health care relevant aspects such as multimorbidity and psychosocial factors in detail. The following article aims to deliver insight into the diversity of the development of National Disease Management Guidelines and to demonstrate the complexity of guideline development.
七年来,德国国家疾病管理指南计划(NDMG计划)一直得到其资助机构的支持:德国医学协会、法定医疗保险医师全国协会和科学医学协会联合会。NDMG计划的目标是制定和实施针对特定疾病管理的全面国家临床指南。NDMG方法的关键点是严格遵循循证医学原则,并通过中立主持的共识会议避免相互矛盾的建议。尽管采用了标准化的NDMG方法,但每个指南都有使其独特的个体结构和内容特征。例如,2型糖尿病这种复杂疾病类型在以主题和问题为导向的NDMG模块中呈现。对于单相抑郁症,NDMG同时被制定为S3指南。此外,每个NDMG小组都面临着各自基于内容的挑战。例如,在NDMG腰痛指南中,指南小组对非特异性腰痛的定义进行了激烈且有争议的讨论。NDMG哮喘指南不仅涉及成年人,还涉及儿童和青少年,而NDMG心力衰竭指南首次详细涵盖了其他与医疗保健相关的方面,如共病和社会心理因素。以下文章旨在深入了解国家疾病管理指南制定的多样性,并展示指南制定的复杂性。