Townsend Robert, Schapmire Darrell W, St James James, Feeler Larry
WCS Occupational Rehabilitation Sports Medicine, Naperville, IL, USA.
Work. 2010;37(4):387-94. doi: 10.3233/WOR-2010-1092.
The purpose of this study was to determine if these two commonly-administered isometric tests are accurate indices of effort.
34 healthy subjects were tested once giving a maximum voluntary effort and once attempting to feign weakness of 50% of maximum.
During feigned weakness sessions, 20 of 34 subjects (58.5%), produced CVs of 15% or less during the Leg Lift. At the 95% CI, the expected frequency of false negatives for feigned weakness is 42.3 to 75.3% for the Leg Lift. At the 95% CI, the expected frequency of false negatives for feigned weakness is 51.9% to 83.3% for the Arm Lift.
Neither isometric lift is appropriate for classifying validity of effort. Use of these isometric lifts should be discontinued for the assessment of effort.
