Peräkylä Anssi
Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies, University of Helsinki, 00014 Helsinki, Finland.
Int J Psychoanal. 2010 Dec;91(6):1363-84. doi: 10.1111/j.1745-8315.2010.00323.x. Epub 2010 Aug 31.
Psychoanalytic interpretation is normally understood as a sequence of two utterances: the analyst gives an interpretation and the patient responds to it. This paper suggests that, in the interpretative sequence, there is also a third utterance where psychoanalytic work takes place. This third interpretative turn involves the analyst's action after the patient's response to the interpretation. Using conversation analysis as method in the examination of audio-recorded psychoanalytic sessions, the paper will explicate the psychoanalytic work that gets done in third interpretative turns. Through it, the analyst takes a stance towards the patient's understandings of the interpretation, which are shown in the patient's response to the interpretation. The third interpretative turns on one hand ratify and accept the patient's understandings, but, in addition to that, they also introduce a shift of perspective relative to them. In most cases, the shift of perspective is implicit but sometimes it is made explicit. The shifts of perspective bring to the foreground aspects or implications of the interpretation that were not incorporated in the patient's response. They recast the description of the patient's experience by showing new layers or more emotional intensity in it. The results are discussed in the light of Faimberg's concept of listening to listening and Schlesinger's concept of follow-up interpretation.
分析师给出一种解释,患者对此做出回应。本文认为,在这个解释序列中,还存在第三个话语环节,精神分析工作在这个环节展开。这第三个解释环节涉及患者对解释做出回应后分析师的行动。本文将以会话分析为方法,对录音的精神分析治疗过程进行考察,阐述在第三个解释环节中所完成的精神分析工作。通过这一环节,分析师对患者对解释的理解采取一种立场,这种理解在患者对解释的回应中得以体现。第三个解释环节一方面认可并接受患者的理解,但除此之外,它们还相对于这些理解引入了一种视角的转变。在大多数情况下,视角的转变是隐含的,但有时也会变得明确。视角的转变将解释中未被纳入患者回应的方面或含义凸显出来。它们通过展现患者体验的新层次或更强的情感强度,重塑了对患者体验的描述。本文将根据法伊姆伯格的“倾听倾听”概念和施莱辛格的“后续解释”概念来讨论这些结果。