Salerno-Kennedy Rossana, Henn Pat, O'Flynn Siun
School of Medicine, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Clin Teach. 2010 Jun;7(2):83-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1743-498X.2010.00354.x.
In modern times, peer tutoring methods have been explored in health care education for over 30 years. In this paper, we report our experience of implementing a peer-tutoring approach to Clinical Skills Laboratory (CSL) training in the Graduate Entry in Medicine Programme (GEM) at University College Cork.
Eighteen fourth-year medical students were recruited as peer tutors for CSL sessions on physical examination. In order to standardise the process, we developed a training course for peer tutors that comprised two stages. They then ran the practical sessions with junior students, under the watchful eye of medical educators. At the end of the last CSL session, the students were given 10 minutes to reflect individually on the experience, and were asked to complete a feedback form.
Twenty-four of the 42 GEM students and six of the seven Senior Tutors (STs) completed and returned their feedback forms. With the caveats of small sample sizes and low response rates, both groups reported that they had both positive and negative experiences of peer tutoring, but that the positive experiences predominated.
The overall experience was positive. In terms of the primary thesis of this study, the STs thought that they were well prepared by the teaching staff to take part in these teaching sessions.
在现代,同伴辅导方法已在医疗保健教育领域探索了30多年。在本文中,我们报告了在科克大学医学研究生入学计划(GEM)中实施同伴辅导方法进行临床技能实验室(CSL)培训的经验。
招募了18名四年级医学生作为体格检查CSL课程的同伴辅导员。为了使过程标准化,我们为同伴辅导员开发了一个包括两个阶段的培训课程。然后,他们在医学教育工作者的密切关注下,与低年级学生一起进行实践课程。在最后一次CSL课程结束时,学生们有10分钟时间单独反思这段经历,并被要求填写一份反馈表。
42名GEM学生中的24名以及7名高级辅导员(ST)中的6名完成并返回了他们的反馈表。尽管存在样本量小和回复率低的问题,但两组都报告说他们在同伴辅导中既有积极的经历,也有消极的经历,但积极经历占主导。
总体体验是积极的。就本研究的主要论点而言,高级辅导员认为教学人员让他们为参与这些教学课程做好了充分准备。