Thompson Catherine
Bristol East Support and Recovery Team, Speedwell Centre, Bristol, UK.
Clin Teach. 2010 Sep;7(3):197-201. doi: 10.1111/j.1743-498X.2010.00381.x.
Problem-based learning (PBL) and interprofessional education (IPE) are becoming increasingly well-established concepts in modern undergraduate medical school curricula. The delivery of IPE through a PBL setting appears to hold good face validity. However, there has to date been no published review of the evidence for the value of combining these two teaching methods.
A review of the literature regarding the use of IPE and PBL together. Firstly the rationale for delivering IPE though PBL is examined and reviewed. Secondly the current evidence for the efficacy of such a model is reviewed.
The current rationales for delivering IPE though PBL are presented. The practical and theoretical barriers to delivering IPE though PBL are presented. The current evidence base regarding outcomes for delivery of IPE through PBL is presented with reference to student knowledge, skills, attitudinal outcomes and facilitator views.
There is favourable evidence for IPE within PBL settings improving attitudes towards other professional groups, and thus fulfilling one of the main aims of IPE. Little is known regarding knowledge and skills outcomes for this model. Facilitator views of the model appear favourable. Collaboration between IPE and PBL appears to be most appropriate for areas of the curriculum that will have relevance for all in their professional lives. It is suggested that delivery of IPE though PBL could fulfil a major role in improving interprofessional relations, and ultimately patient care. If true IPE PBL groups are to be implemented within curricula. The impact this will have on resources and the cross-professional planning needed will be considerable.
基于问题的学习(PBL)和跨专业教育(IPE)在现代本科医学院课程中已日益成为既定的概念。通过PBL环境开展IPE似乎具有良好的表面效度。然而,迄今为止,尚未有关于结合这两种教学方法价值的证据的发表综述。
对有关同时使用IPE和PBL的文献进行综述。首先,审视并回顾通过PBL开展IPE的基本原理。其次,回顾关于这种模式有效性的现有证据。
阐述了通过PBL开展IPE的当前基本原理。提出了通过PBL开展IPE的实际和理论障碍。参照学生知识、技能、态度成果以及促进者的观点,呈现了关于通过PBL开展IPE的结果的现有证据基础。
有有利证据表明,PBL环境中的IPE改善了对其他专业群体的态度,从而实现了IPE的主要目标之一。对于该模式的知识和技能成果知之甚少。促进者对该模式的看法似乎是积极的。IPE和PBL之间的协作似乎最适用于课程中与所有人职业生活相关的领域。有人认为,通过PBL开展IPE在改善跨专业关系以及最终改善患者护理方面可以发挥重要作用。如果要在课程中实施真正的IPE-PBL小组,这将对资源产生的影响以及所需的跨专业规划将是巨大的。