Kobayashi Yukihiro, Uehara Takeshi, Ota Hiroyoshi
Department of Laboratory Medicine, School of Health Sciences, Shinshu University, Matsumoto, Japan.
Acta Cytol. 2011;55(1):69-78. doi: 10.1159/000320872. Epub 2010 Nov 26.
The aim of this study was to evaluate liquid-based preparations (LBP) as a replacement for conventional smears (CS) of bronchial brushing (BB) and transbronchial fine-needle aspiration (TBNA) samples obtained via fiberoptic bronchoscope.
Bronchial brushing and TBNA samples were obtained from 62 and 33 patients by fiberoptic bronchoscopy, respectively. Liquid-based preparations were prepared from needle rinse after initial CS preparation. We compared cellularity, cell morphology, and background between the LBP and CS slides.
Correspondence rates between LBP and CS diagnoses in the above 3 categories were 90.3% in the BB and 97.0% in the TBNA samples. If suspicious cases were regarded as malignant, correspondence rates reached 98.4 and 100%, respectively. Histological diagnoses by LBP were mostly the same as those by CS and by biopsy or operation samples. Morphologically, cells and nuclei were shrunk in the LBP; however, the shrinking was not severe enough to influence cytological diagnoses. Blood background and air-drying, which were observed on many of the CS slides, were not detected on the LBP slides.
It is possible to use LBP for routine laboratory processing of BB and TBNA samples as a replacement for CS.
本研究旨在评估液基制剂(LBP)作为通过纤维支气管镜获取的支气管刷检(BB)和经支气管细针穿刺抽吸(TBNA)样本的传统涂片(CS)的替代方法。
分别通过纤维支气管镜从62例和33例患者中获取支气管刷检和TBNA样本。在最初制备CS后,从针冲洗液中制备液基制剂。我们比较了LBP和CS玻片之间的细胞数量、细胞形态和背景。
上述3类中LBP和CS诊断之间的符合率在BB样本中为90.3%,在TBNA样本中为97.0%。如果将可疑病例视为恶性,则符合率分别达到98.4%和100%。LBP的组织学诊断大多与CS以及活检或手术样本的诊断相同。形态学上,LBP中的细胞和细胞核缩小;然而,缩小程度不足以影响细胞学诊断。在许多CS玻片上观察到的血液背景和空气干燥现象,在LBP玻片上未检测到。
可以使用LBP对BB和TBNA样本进行常规实验室处理,以替代CS。