Arnau Miquel Monras
Instituto de Neurociencias, Hospital Clínico de Barcelona, Spain.
Adicciones. 2010;22(4):339-52.
Alcoholic men and women have differential characteristics. It has been discussed whether alcoholic women have specific and additional difficulties that require extra study. However, these differences may imply an advantage for some aspects of treatment.
data from eleven published studies of alcoholic patients are reanalyzed from a gender perspective.
to gain better knowledge of gender differences and their therapeutic implications.
women present more suicidal attempts than men, but these attempts are less lethal and have less intentionality. Personality structure is similar in the two sexes, but women have better prognosis, even if they present psychiatric disorders. A notable characteristic of women's prognosis is their better adherence to group therapies. Women diagnosed with severe alcohol dependence who need inpatient treatment for detoxification are usually younger and have higher rates of benzodiazepine abuse and personality disorders than men, but are also more collaborative, and benefit more from therapy. Female benzodiazepine abusers show lower rates of neurocognitive impairment than men. Alcoholic women with severe organic conditions that require inpatient treatment usually have a medical record with more unsuccessful treatment attempts for alcohol dependence than men, and their prognosis is equally unfavourable.
alcoholic women may have psychological mechanisms that facilitate higher abstinence rates and lower mortality rates than men. Future research for improving knowledge of such mechanisms, which are related to emotional factors such as guilt, depression and anxiety, and traditionally considered as problematic, may indicate that they actually increase motivation to change.
酗酒的男性和女性具有不同的特征。人们一直在讨论酗酒女性是否存在需要额外研究的特殊和附加困难。然而,这些差异可能在某些治疗方面意味着一种优势。
从性别角度对11项已发表的酗酒患者研究数据进行重新分析。
更好地了解性别差异及其治疗意义。
女性的自杀未遂次数比男性多,但这些未遂的致死性较低且故意性较小。两性的人格结构相似,但女性的预后较好,即使她们患有精神疾病。女性预后的一个显著特征是她们对团体治疗的依从性更好。被诊断为严重酒精依赖且需要住院戒毒治疗的女性通常比男性更年轻,苯二氮䓬滥用率和人格障碍发生率更高,但她们也更合作,从治疗中获益更多。女性苯二氮䓬滥用者的神经认知障碍发生率低于男性。患有需要住院治疗的严重器质性疾病的酗酒女性,其酒精依赖治疗尝试失败的病历记录通常比男性更多,且预后同样不佳。
酗酒女性可能具有一些心理机制,这些机制有助于她们比男性有更高的戒酒率和更低的死亡率。未来关于增进对此类与内疚、抑郁和焦虑等情绪因素相关且传统上被视为有问题的机制的认识的研究,可能表明它们实际上会增加改变的动力。