Department of Psychology, Ohio University, Athens, OH 45701, USA.
AIDS Behav. 2011 Feb;15(2):441-53. doi: 10.1007/s10461-010-9854-1.
Measurement invariance is the extent to which scales have the same meaning across groups, a condition that is necessary prior to conducting between-group comparisons. As stress and coping research increasingly examines the adjustment efforts of African Americans and Caucasians living with chronic health conditions, it is first necessary to assess the equivalence of existing stress and coping measures for both racial groups. This study examined the psychometric properties and measurement invariance of four measures used frequently in stress and coping research. African Americans (n = 204) and Caucasians (n = 83) completed pre- and post-intervention surveys as part of a randomized clinical trial that tested if telephone-administered psychotherapies could reduce depressive symptoms in persons living with HIV/AIDS. Participants completed the ways of coping checklist (WOCC), the coping self-efficacy scale (CSES), the provision of social relations scale (PSRS), and the geriatric depression scale (GDS). Several WOCC subscales initially evidenced poor internal consistency (when computed using summated composites) that improved when measurement models were applied. The 12-week test-retest reliabilities of PSRS total and subscale scores were notably lower in African Americans than Caucasians. Analyses of race-related measurement invariance showed acceptable invariance for the GDS and the CSES but less certain invariance for the WOCC and PSRS. Stress and coping researchers should examine carefully the psychometric properties of study measures within and between racial groups prior to conducting tests of between-group differences.
测量不变性是指量表在不同群体中的含义是否相同,这是进行群体间比较的必要条件。随着压力和应对研究越来越多地考察患有慢性疾病的非裔美国人和白种人的调整努力,首先有必要评估现有压力和应对措施在这两个种族群体中的等效性。本研究考察了常用于压力和应对研究的四种测量方法的心理测量特性和测量不变性。非裔美国人(n=204)和白种人(n=83)作为一项随机临床试验的一部分完成了干预前和干预后的调查,该试验测试了电话管理的心理疗法是否可以减轻艾滋病毒/艾滋病患者的抑郁症状。参与者完成了应对方式检查表(WOCC)、应对自我效能感量表(CSES)、提供社会关系量表(PSRS)和老年抑郁量表(GDS)。最初,几个 WOCC 分量表的内部一致性较差(当使用总和复合计算时),而当应用测量模型时,一致性得到了提高。PSRS 总分和分量表得分的 12 周重测信度在非裔美国人群体中明显低于白种人群体。种族相关测量不变性分析表明,GDS 和 CSES 的不变性可接受,但 WOCC 和 PSRS 的不变性不太确定。压力和应对研究人员在进行群体间差异测试之前,应仔细检查研究测量方法在群体内和群体间的心理测量特性。