Department of Anesthesia, Ube Industries Central Hospital, 750 Nishikiwa, Ube 755-0151, Japan.
J Anesth. 2011 Feb;25(1):72-7. doi: 10.1007/s00540-010-1050-y. Epub 2010 Dec 14.
We planned a survey to evaluate the current incidence and risk factors of intraoperative awareness.
A questionnaire survey was conducted via the Internet. The survey was designed to obtain information regarding cases involving intraoperative awareness in 2008.
A total of 172 anesthesiologists answered the survey. The total number of reported anesthetic cases was 85,156. Twenty-four cases of definite or possible awareness were reported by 21 anesthesiologists, of which 14 were cases of definite awareness and ten of possible awareness. The incidence of awareness, including possible awareness, was 0.028%. Propofol was used in 21 cases, sevoflurane in two, and a high dose of fentanyl in one. Bispectral index (BIS) monitoring was used in seven cases (29%). Sixteen patients (67%) were <50 years old, six (26%) were men, and 17 (74%) were women. As the type of surgery, three cases (13%) involved gynecological surgeries and seven (30%) involved cervicofacial surgeries. During surgery, the memory at postural change was preserved in two cases.
The most surprising finding of this study is that total intravenous anesthesia (TIVA) was used in 21 of the 24 (88%) cases of definite and possible awareness. Although the incidence of intraoperative awareness was compatible with the previous studies, meticulous care should be taken when anesthesia is performed by TIVA for high-risk patients. The results of this survey should be verified, as well as further continuous survey and prospective study, because this study was performed by an anonymous questionnaire survey conducted over only 1-year period.
我们计划进行一项调查,以评估术中知晓的当前发生率和危险因素。
通过互联网进行问卷调查。该调查旨在获取 2008 年涉及术中知晓的病例信息。
共有 172 名麻醉师回答了调查。报告的麻醉病例总数为 85156 例。21 名麻醉师报告了 24 例明确或可能的知晓病例,其中 14 例为明确知晓,10 例为可能知晓。知晓的发生率(包括可能知晓)为 0.028%。21 例使用了丙泊酚,2 例使用了七氟醚,1 例使用了高剂量芬太尼。7 例(29%)使用了脑电双频指数(BIS)监测。16 例患者(67%)<50 岁,6 例(26%)为男性,17 例(74%)为女性。手术类型方面,3 例(13%)为妇科手术,7 例(30%)为颈面部手术。在手术过程中,2 例患者在体位改变时有记忆。
这项研究最令人惊讶的发现是,在 24 例明确和可能的知晓病例中,有 21 例(88%)使用了全凭静脉麻醉(TIVA)。尽管术中知晓的发生率与之前的研究相符,但在为高危患者进行 TIVA 麻醉时应格外小心。由于这项研究仅通过为期 1 年的匿名问卷调查进行,因此应验证该结果,并进一步进行持续调查和前瞻性研究。