Moksnes Kjell Martin, Ilner Stein Opjordsmoen
Department of Geriatric Psychiatry, Mental Health and Dependence Clinic, Oslo University Hospital, Slottsberget 35, 1385 Asker, Norway.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2010 Dec 16;130(24):2460-4. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.09.1102.
Efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and duration of associated side effects is uncertain. We wanted to study indications, efficacy, time to response and side effects.
ECT-protocols and medical records (from the period 1960-95) in three psychiatric wards of Dikemark Mental Hospital, Norway were systematically assessed.
141 persons underwent 241 ECT series comprising 1960 treatment sessions. Major depressive disorder was the main diagnosis in most patients 124 [88 %]. Before ECT, 129 (91 %) patients had been treated with at least one antidepressant, 107 (76 %) with at least two and 67 (48 %) with two different classes of antidepressants without sufficient clinical recovery from the incident. 31 (22 %) had received lithium before ECT. Within four weeks after the first ECT, 120 (85 %) patients had recovered. 61 of these achieved remission and were discharged within four weeks. After the first ECT series, 92 patients showed signs of improvement. 71 (77 %) had signs of improvement within 6 days. Side effects were noted after 123 of totally 241 series (51 %). Five patients experienced serious complications. Interpretation. The immediate effect of ECT was good and signs of recovery were observed in most patients during the first week. Depressed psychotic patients and the elderly seemed to respond best. Considering these patients' serious and long-lasting disorders ECT was fairly safe and well tolerated.
电休克疗法(ECT)的疗效以及相关副作用的持续时间尚不确定。我们希望研究其适应症、疗效、起效时间和副作用。
对挪威迪克马克精神病院三个精神科病房1960 - 1995年期间的ECT治疗方案和病历进行了系统评估。
141人接受了241个ECT疗程,共1960次治疗。大多数患者(124例[88%])的主要诊断为重度抑郁症。在接受ECT之前,129例(91%)患者至少接受过一种抗抑郁药治疗,107例(76%)至少接受过两种,67例(48%)接受过两种不同类型的抗抑郁药治疗,但均未从病情中获得足够的临床康复。31例(22%)在ECT治疗前接受过锂盐治疗。在首次ECT治疗后的四周内,120例(85%)患者康复。其中61例实现缓解并在四周内出院。在首次ECT疗程后,92例患者有改善迹象。其中71例(77%)在6天内出现改善迹象。在总共241个疗程中,123个疗程(51%)出现了副作用。5例患者出现严重并发症。解读:ECT的即时效果良好,大多数患者在第一周内出现康复迹象。抑郁性精神病患者和老年人似乎反应最佳。考虑到这些患者病情严重且持续时间长,ECT相当安全且耐受性良好。