Hvid Marianne, Vangborg Kerstin, Sørensen Holger J, Nielsen Inge K, Stenborg Jan M, Wang August G
Centre of Suicide Prevention, Department of Psychiatry Amager, Copenhagen University Hospital, Digevej 110, DK-2300 Copenhagen S, Denmark.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2011 Oct;65(5):292-8. doi: 10.3109/08039488.2010.544404. Epub 2010 Dec 20.
Repetition after attempted suicide is high but only few effect studies have been carried out. The Baerum Model from Norway offers practical and affordable intervention for those not being offered psychiatric treatment. During a period from 2005-2007, all attempted suicide patients except those with major psychiatric diagnoses (schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, severe/psychotic depression), were offered participation. The intervention group received the OPAC programme (outreach, problem solving, adherence, continuity) and the control group received treatment as usual (TAU). The intervention period was 6 months. After this intervention period, all patients were followed passively for an extra 6 months. The design was an intent-to-treat one. The outcomes were: 1) repetition of attempted suicide or suicide, and 2) total number of suicidal acts. A total of 200 patients were offered participation, 67 refused. Of the 133 participants, 69 were randomized to the OPAC programme and 64 to the (non-intervention) control group. Four in each group dropped out after initial participation. There was a significant lower proportion who repeated a suicide attempt the intervention group (proportion 8.7%) than in the control group (proportion 21.9%) and the number of repetitive acts was also significant lower (eight repetitions in the intervention group vs. 22 in the control group). In conclusion, our findings suggest a protective effect of the OPAC programme on the proportion who repeated a suicide attempt and on the total number of repetitions during the follow-up.
自杀未遂后的重复发生率很高,但仅有少数效果研究。挪威的贝鲁姆模式为那些未接受精神科治疗的人提供了实用且经济实惠的干预措施。在2005年至2007年期间,除患有重度精神疾病诊断(精神分裂症、双相情感障碍、重度/精神病性抑郁症)的自杀未遂患者外,所有患者均被邀请参与。干预组接受OPAC项目(外展、解决问题、依从性、连续性),对照组接受常规治疗(TAU)。干预期为6个月。在此干预期后,所有患者被额外被动随访6个月。该设计为意向性治疗设计。结果为:1)自杀未遂或自杀的重复发生,以及2)自杀行为的总数。共有200名患者被邀请参与,67人拒绝。在133名参与者中,69人被随机分配到OPAC项目组,64人被分配到(非干预)对照组。每组各有4人在初次参与后退出。干预组中自杀未遂重复发生的比例(8.7%)显著低于对照组(21.9%),重复行为的数量也显著更低(干预组8次重复,对照组22次重复)。总之,我们的研究结果表明OPAC项目对随访期间自杀未遂重复发生的比例和重复总数具有保护作用。