Steinberg Peter L, Nangia Ajay K, Curtis Kevin
Section of Urology, Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, New Hampshire, USA.
Qual Manag Health Care. 2011 Jan-Mar;20(1):30-6. doi: 10.1097/QMH.0b013e31820429d9.
Kidney stones are a common, and extremely painful, cause of emergency department (ED) visits. Pain management is a critical component of high-quality patient care. A pilot study at our institution found that only 69% of ED patients with renal colic had evidence of clinically significant analgesia.
In response to these findings, we evaluated the impact of a formalized pain management protocol on timeliness of analgesia among ED patients with renal colic.
Using a before and after study design, adult ED patients with renal colic were eligible. In the prospective arm, patients were treated with ketorolac, 30 mg intravenous, and morphine, 0.05-0.1 mg/kg intravenous, according to a standardized protocol. Results were compared with a retrospective chart review of eligible patients treated during a similar preprotocol period.
Implementation of the protocol resulted in a significant reduction in time to effective analgesia (72 ± 63 vs 37 ± 42 minutes, P = .003). The protocol did not result in any increase in adverse effects.
Implementation of a standardized pain management protocol among ED patients with renal colic resulted in a marked improvement in quality of care as evidenced by a 49% reduction in time to effective analgesia.
肾结石是急诊科就诊的常见且极为疼痛的原因。疼痛管理是高质量患者护理的关键组成部分。我们机构的一项试点研究发现,只有69%的肾绞痛急诊患者有临床显著镇痛的证据。
针对这些发现,我们评估了正式疼痛管理方案对肾绞痛急诊患者镇痛及时性的影响。
采用前后对照研究设计,纳入成年肾绞痛急诊患者。在前瞻性组中,根据标准化方案,患者接受静脉注射30mg酮咯酸和静脉注射0.05 - 0.1mg/kg吗啡治疗。将结果与类似方案实施前时期接受治疗的符合条件患者的回顾性病历审查结果进行比较。
方案实施后,有效镇痛时间显著缩短(72±63分钟对37±42分钟,P = 0.003)。该方案未导致不良反应增加。
在肾绞痛急诊患者中实施标准化疼痛管理方案导致护理质量显著提高,有效镇痛时间减少49%即为明证。