Máxima Medical Centre, Clinical Laboratory, De Run 4600, 5504 DB Veldhoven, The Netherlands.
J Clin Microbiol. 2011 Mar;49(3):1025-9. doi: 10.1128/JCM.01669-10. Epub 2011 Jan 19.
The diagnosis of urinary tract infection (UTI) by urine culture is time-consuming and can produce up to 60 to 80% negative results. Fast screening methods that can reduce the necessity for urine cultures will have a large impact on overall turnaround time and laboratory economics. We have evaluated the detection of bacteria and leukocytes by a new urine analyzer, the UF-1000i, to identify negative urine samples that can be excluded from urine culture. In total, 1,577 urine samples were analyzed and compared to urine culture. Urine culture showed growth of ≥10(3) CFU/ml in 939 samples (60%). Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves and ROC decision plots were been prepared at three different gold standard definitions of a negative urine culture: no growth, growth of bacteria at <10(4) CFU/ml, and growth of bacteria at <10(5) CFU/ml. Also, the reduction in urine cultures and the percentage of false negatives were calculated. At the most stringent gold standard definition of no growth, a chosen sensitivity of 95% resulted in a cutoff value of 26 bacteria/μl, a specificity of 43% and a reduction in urine cultures of only 20%, of which 14% were false negatives. However, at a gold standard definition of <10(5) CFU/ml and a sensitivity of 95%, the UF-1000i cutoff value was 230 bacteria/μl, the specificity was 80%, and the reduction in urine cultures was 52%, of which 0.3% were false negatives. The applicability of the UF-1000i to screen for negative urine samples strongly depends on population characteristics and the definition of a negative urine culture. In our setting, however, the low workload savings and the high percentage of false-negative results do not warrant the UF-1000i to be used as a screening analyzer.
尿路感染(UTI)的诊断通过尿液培养是耗时的,并且可以产生多达 60%至 80%的阴性结果。能够减少尿液培养需求的快速筛选方法将对整体周转时间和实验室经济学产生重大影响。我们评估了新的尿液分析仪 UF-1000i 对细菌和白细胞的检测,以识别可以从尿液培养中排除的阴性尿液样本。总共分析了 1577 个尿液样本,并与尿液培养进行了比较。尿液培养显示,939 个样本(60%)中≥10(3)CFU/ml 的细菌生长。在三个不同的阴性尿液培养金标准定义下,绘制了接收者操作特性(ROC)曲线和 ROC 决策图:无生长、细菌生长<10(4)CFU/ml 和细菌生长<10(5)CFU/ml。此外,还计算了尿液培养的减少和假阴性的百分比。在最严格的无生长金标准定义下,选择 95%的灵敏度导致截断值为 26 个细菌/μl,特异性为 43%,尿液培养的减少仅为 20%,其中 14%为假阴性。然而,在<10(5)CFU/ml 的金标准定义和 95%的灵敏度下,UF-1000i 的截断值为 230 个细菌/μl,特异性为 80%,尿液培养的减少为 52%,其中 0.3%为假阴性。UF-1000i 用于筛选阴性尿液样本的适用性强烈取决于人群特征和阴性尿液培养的定义。然而,在我们的环境中,低工作负荷节省和高假阴性率结果并不证明 UF-1000i 可以用作筛选分析仪。