Division of Periodontology, College of Dentistry, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40536-0297, USA.
J Periodontol. 2011 Sep;82(9):1288-94. doi: 10.1902/jop.2011.100270. Epub 2011 Feb 2.
General dental practitioners (GPs) assess the periodontal status of patients and make decisions to treat patients or refer them to a periodontist. There is little information available regarding this process. The purpose of this study is to identify significant factors that GPs consider important in selecting a particular periodontist. The findings were compared and contrasted with responses of periodontists to gain perspectives from both groups involved in the referral process.
Data from an online cross-sectional survey of GPs (n = 533) and periodontists (n = 533) who practice in the southeastern region of the United States (from the databases of the American Dental Association and American Academy of Periodontology member directories) were obtained.
The specialist's clinical skill was identified as the most important factor influencing periodontal referrals by GPs, whereas periodontists identified a previous positive experience between a GP and periodontist as the most important factor. In a descending order of importance, the top three rating averages (rated out of five) by GPs were clinical skill (4.84), a previous positive experience between a GP and periodontist (4.57), and communication (4.52). The top three factors of periodontists were a previous positive experience between a GP and periodontist (4.66), communication (4.40), and the likelihood of a good patient and periodontist rapport (4.29).
The periodontist's clinical skill was chosen by GPs as the primary factor influencing the referral decisions of GPs. Periodontists perceived a previous positive experience between the GP and periodontist as the most influential factor. Further studies are required to gain more insight into the referral process.
全科牙医(GPs)评估患者的牙周状况并做出治疗或转诊给牙周病医生的决策。关于这个过程的信息很少。本研究的目的是确定 GP 认为在选择特定牙周病医生时重要的因素。将这些发现与牙周病医生的反应进行比较和对比,以从参与转诊过程的两个群体中获得观点。
从美国东南部地区(美国牙科协会和牙周病学会成员名录数据库)的全科牙医(n=533)和牙周病医生(n=533)的在线横断面调查中获取数据。
专家的临床技能被认为是影响 GP 牙周转诊的最重要因素,而牙周病医生则认为 GP 和牙周病医生之间以前的积极经验是最重要的因素。按照重要性降序排列,GP 的平均排名前三位(五分制)为临床技能(4.84)、GP 和牙周病医生之间以前的积极经验(4.57)和沟通(4.52)。牙周病医生的前三个因素是 GP 和牙周病医生之间以前的积极经验(4.66)、沟通(4.40)和良好的医患关系(4.29)。
GP 选择牙周病医生的临床技能作为影响 GP 转诊决策的主要因素。牙周病医生认为 GP 和牙周病医生之间以前的积极经验是最具影响力的因素。需要进一步研究以更深入地了解转诊过程。