Twig Gilad, Lahad Amnon, Kochba Ilan, Ezra Vered, Mandel Dror, Shina Avi, Kreiss Yitshak, Zimlichman Eyal
Medicine Branch, Surgeon's General Headquarters, Medical Corps, Israel Defense Forces, Israel.
Isr Med Assoc J. 2010 Sep;12(9):521-5.
A survey conducted among Israel Defense Force primary care physicians in 2001 revealed that they consider patients' needs more than they do organizational needs and that the education PCPs currently receive is inadequate. In 2003 the medical corps initiated a multi-format continuous medical education program aimed at improving skills in primary care medicine.
To measure and analyze the effect of the tailor-made CME program on PCPs' self-perception 3 years after its implementation and correlate it to clinical performance.
In 2006 a questionnaire was delivered to a representative sample of PCPs in the IDF. The questionnaire included items on demographic and professional background, statements on self-perception issues, and ranking of roles. We compared the follow-up survey (2006) to the results of the original study (2001) and correlated the survey results with clinical performance as measured through objective indicators.
In the 2006 follow-up survey PCPs scored higher on questions dealing with their perception of themselves as case managers (3.8 compared to 4.0 on the 2001 survey on a 5 point scale, P = 0.046), perceived quality of care and education (3.5 vs. 3.8, P = 0.06), and on questions dealing with organizational commitment (3.5 vs. 3.8, P = 0.01). PCPs received higher scores on clinical indicators in the later study (odds ratio 2.05, P < 0.001).
PCPs in the IDF perceived themselves more as case managers as compared to the 2001 survey. A tailor-made CME program may have contributed to the improvement in skills and quality of care.
2001年对以色列国防军初级保健医生进行的一项调查显示,他们更关注患者需求而非组织需求,且目前初级保健医生所接受的教育并不充分。2003年,医疗队启动了一项多形式的继续医学教育项目,旨在提高初级保健医学技能。
评估并分析量身定制的继续医学教育项目在实施3年后对初级保健医生自我认知的影响,并将其与临床绩效相关联。
2006年,向以色列国防军初级保健医生的一个代表性样本发放了问卷。问卷包括人口统计学和专业背景项目、自我认知问题陈述以及角色排名。我们将后续调查(2006年)与原始研究(2001年)的结果进行了比较,并将调查结果与通过客观指标衡量的临床绩效相关联。
在2006年的后续调查中,初级保健医生在将自己视为病例管理者的认知问题上得分更高(在5分制量表上,2001年调查得分为4.0,此次得分为3.8,P = 0.046),在感知护理和教育质量方面得分更高(3.5对3.8,P = 0.06),在处理组织承诺的问题上得分也更高(3.5对3.8,P = 0.01)。在后续研究中,初级保健医生在临床指标上得分更高(优势比为2.05,P < 0.001)。
与2001年的调查相比,以色列国防军的初级保健医生更将自己视为病例管理者。量身定制的继续医学教育项目可能有助于技能和护理质量的提高。