Armstrong R J, Rosser A E, Dunnett S B, Barker R A
Cambridge Centre for Brain Repair, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Methods Mol Med. 2001;62:289-307. doi: 10.1385/1-59259-142-6:289.
The transplantation of human fetal ventral mesencephalic (VM) tissue for patients with advanced Parkinson's disease (PD) has now proved to be of benefit in early clinical trials (1-3). This has been clearly seen in terms of improved motor function, which has been correlated with increased fluorodopa signal on positron emission tomographic scanning at the site of the implant and the presence of abundant tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)-positive neurons in those patients who have come to postmortem analysis (4,5). However, although the concept of restoration of function through neural transplantation is promising, there are major practical as well as ethical problems with the use of aborted human fetal tissue. In particular, aborted fetal tissue is not available in many countries, and even where it can be obtained, isolation of the VM from the large numbers of fetuses the procedure requires presents major logistical difficulties. For example, in PD the best results have been obtained using an average of six to eight fetuses per patient. Therefore, the search for alternative sources of tissue for transplantation is imperative if the procedure is to be widely adopted in the clinical domain. A number of possibilities are currently being explored experimentally (see Table 1), although all of them present difficulties that must be overcome before they can be adopted clinically (reviewed in ref. 6). Table 1 Alternatives to Primary Human Neuronal Cells for Transplantation in PD Dopamine-containing polymers that release dopamine slowly over months/years. Catecholamine-producing cells found naturally within the adult, which may thus be suitable for autotransplantation, e.g., adrenal medulla, carotid body, superior cervical ganglion. Catecholamine-producing cell lines that may be encapsulated to prevent rejection and spread of the tumour cells out into the host brain, e.g., PC12 cells. Cells transfected with tyrosine hydroxylase, which potentially allows for the possibility of autotransplantation, e.g., skin fibroblasts. Xenografts of dopamine-rich tissue, e.g., embryonic porcine ventral mesencephalic tissue. Neural stem cells. Embryonic stem (ES) cells.
将人胎儿腹侧中脑(VM)组织移植给晚期帕金森病(PD)患者,现已在早期临床试验中证明是有益的(1 - 3)。从运动功能改善方面可以清楚地看到这一点,运动功能改善与植入部位正电子发射断层扫描上氟多巴信号增加以及尸检分析的患者中存在大量酪氨酸羟化酶(TH)阳性神经元相关(4,5)。然而,尽管通过神经移植恢复功能的概念很有前景,但使用流产的人胎儿组织存在重大的实际和伦理问题。特别是,许多国家无法获得流产胎儿组织,即使在可以获得的地方,从该手术所需的大量胎儿中分离VM也存在重大后勤困难。例如,在帕金森病中,每位患者平均使用六到八个胎儿可获得最佳结果。因此,如果该手术要在临床领域广泛应用,寻找替代移植组织来源势在必行。目前正在通过实验探索多种可能性(见表1),尽管所有这些都存在在临床应用之前必须克服的困难(参考文献6综述)。表1帕金森病移植中替代原代人神经元细胞的方法含多巴胺的聚合物,可在数月/数年中缓慢释放多巴胺。成人体内天然存在的产生儿茶酚胺的细胞,因此可能适合自体移植,例如肾上腺髓质、颈动脉体、颈上神经节。可封装以防止肿瘤细胞排斥和扩散到宿主脑内的产生儿茶酚胺的细胞系,例如PC12细胞。用酪氨酸羟化酶转染的细胞,这可能允许自体移植的可能性,例如皮肤成纤维细胞。富含多巴胺组织的异种移植物,例如胚胎猪腹侧中脑组织。神经干细胞。胚胎干细胞(ES细胞)。