Laubjerg Merete, Petersson Birgit
Unit of Women and Gender Research in Medicine, Section of General Practice, Institute of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2011 Dec;65(6):365-72. doi: 10.3109/08039488.2011.558115. Epub 2011 Feb 18.
Research stresses that adoptees are at high risk of psychiatric contact, but are they also more likely to be at risk of juvenile delinquency? The aim is to clarify whether the variable "adoptee" is an independent risk factor for criminal conviction and to highlight relationships between convictions and their relapses and psychiatric contacts.
A nationwide comparative register-based study, 1994-2004. The cohort is composed of 282,986 individuals aged 15-27, Danish and foreign born (immigrants); 1.3% are adoptees, included adopted stepchildren.
The variable "adoptee" is not a risk factor for transnational adoptees and Danish ≤12 months at adoption, but Danish adoptees >12 months at adoption and adopted stepchildren have a 3-4 times higher risk than non-adoptees. However, "country of origin" has a negative impact on foreign-born adoptees and foreign-born non-adoptees. "Age at adoption", "psychiatric contact" and "not living with parents" (at time of inclusion) are risks of conviction and conviction relapse. Boys are at higher risk than girls, but girls' psychiatric contact is highest. Stepchildren are an overlooked risk group.
"Adoptee", as such, is not a risk factor for convictions, but it seems that it is the way adoption-related matters are handled. Gender-specific care for children and adolescents with new thinking in relation to child relinquishment, institutionalization and mental health care is important to ensure both boys and girls a youth free of crime.
研究强调领养儿童有较高的精神疾病接触风险,但他们是否也更有可能面临青少年犯罪风险呢?目的是阐明“领养儿童”这一变量是否是刑事定罪的独立风险因素,并突出定罪及其复发与精神疾病接触之间的关系。
一项基于全国登记册的比较研究,时间跨度为1994年至2004年。该队列由282,986名年龄在15至27岁之间的丹麦人和外国出生者(移民)组成;1.3%为领养儿童,包括领养继子女。
对于跨国领养儿童以及领养时在丹麦居住≤12个月的儿童,“领养儿童”这一变量不是风险因素,但领养时在丹麦居住>12个月的丹麦领养儿童和领养继子女的风险是非领养儿童的3至4倍。然而,“原籍国”对外国出生的领养儿童和外国出生的非领养儿童有负面影响。“领养时的年龄”、“精神疾病接触”以及(纳入研究时)“不与父母同住”是定罪和定罪复发的风险因素。男孩的风险高于女孩,但女孩的精神疾病接触情况最为严重。继子女是一个被忽视的风险群体。
“领养儿童”本身并非定罪的风险因素,但似乎是领养相关事宜的处理方式起了作用。针对儿童和青少年进行性别特定护理,并在儿童送养、机构收容和精神卫生保健方面采用新思维,对于确保男孩和女孩都能拥有无犯罪的青春岁月至关重要。