Centre for Anxiety Disorders and Trauma, South London and Maudsley NHS Trust, London, UK.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2011 Mar;50(1):7-18. doi: 10.1348/014466510X490073.
A time-intensive format may be both useful and effective for the delivery of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). Intensive treatments also offer a pragmatic alternative to in-patient admission for those in a geographically remote location. Published studies of intensive treatment include pioneering exposure-response prevention (ERP) trials that emphasized the requirement for high-intensity treatment; more recently several studies have used treatment protocols with a heavy emphasis on ERP. This study compares intensive versus standard weekly treatment format following the integrated formulation-driven CBT approach widely used in UK adult mental health settings.
An analysis of patients undertaking intensive CBT using a matched comparison group of those who undertook weekly CBT for OCD.
Twenty-two adult patients undertook intensive format treatment (matched with a weekly group for age, gender, and initial symptoms). A range of self-report measures were examined at the end of treatment and at a 3-month follow-up.
Significant treatment effects were found on a range of self-report measures; both conditions were found to be equally effective at the end of treatment and at 3-month follow-up. Uncontrolled effect sizes show that the intensive treatment was comparable to other trials of CBT for OCD.
An intensive treatment format for the delivery of CBT for OCD was found to be as effective as weekly treatment. This is consistent with the recommendations from the National Institute for Clinical Excellence guidelines. This study adds to the growing literature on the effectiveness of intensive format treatment.
对于强迫症(OCD)的认知行为疗法(CBT)来说,密集型治疗模式可能既有用又有效。对于那些地处偏远地区的患者来说,强化治疗也是住院治疗的一种实用替代方案。已发表的强化治疗研究包括强调高强度治疗要求的开创性暴露反应预防(ERP)试验;最近,有几项研究使用了更加重视 ERP 的治疗方案。本研究比较了广泛应用于英国成人心理健康环境中的整合驱动式 CBT 方法后的强化治疗与标准每周治疗模式。
使用每周接受 OCD 治疗的匹配比较组,对接受密集型 CBT 的患者进行分析。
22 名成年患者接受强化治疗(与每周组在年龄、性别和初始症状方面相匹配)。在治疗结束时和 3 个月随访时检查了一系列自我报告的测量结果。
在一系列自我报告的测量结果中发现了显著的治疗效果;两种治疗在治疗结束时和 3 个月随访时都同样有效。未经控制的效果大小表明,强化治疗与 OCD 的其他 CBT 试验相当。
为 OCD 提供 CBT 的强化治疗模式被发现与每周治疗同样有效。这与国家临床卓越研究所指南的建议一致。本研究增加了关于强化治疗模式有效性的不断增长的文献。