King's College London, Institute of Psychiatry, London, UK.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2010 Jun;49(Pt 2):173-91. doi: 10.1348/014466509X447055. Epub 2009 Aug 28.
An intensive format may be both useful and effective for the delivery of cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). However, the acceptability of an intensive treatment format from the perspective of service users is unknown. This study examines service user perspectives on the acceptability of an intensive versus a standard weekly treatment format.
The study comprises a detailed comparative qualitative analysis of the perspectives of service users who have completed either intensive or weekly CBT for OCD.
Six treatment completers in each format (matched for age, gender, and symptom changeover the course of treatment) were asked to reflect on helpful and problematic aspects of their treatment format, and to consider the differences between treatment formats. The interviews were transcribed and analysed in detail using thematic analysis.
Individual differences were apparent in preference for treatment format. Weekly treatment completers were concerned that intensive treatment could be overwhelming or too brief for real change to take place. However, intensive treatment completers valued the high pressure and pace and felt that it improved motivation, engagement, and eventual outcome.
An intensive treatment format for the delivery of CBT for OCD can be highly motivating and acceptable to service users who have chosen to undertake it. Good quality follow-up and crisis support may be particularly important following intensive treatment.
密集式治疗方案可能对强迫症(OCD)的认知行为疗法(CBT)的实施既有用又有效。然而,服务使用者对密集式治疗方案的可接受性尚不清楚。本研究从服务使用者的角度探讨了密集式与标准每周治疗方案的可接受性。
本研究对接受密集式或每周 CBT 治疗 OCD 的完成治疗的服务使用者的观点进行了详细的对比定性分析。
对每种治疗方案(按年龄、性别和治疗过程中的症状变化进行匹配)各有 6 名治疗完成者,要求他们反思治疗方案的有益和有问题的方面,并考虑治疗方案之间的差异。对访谈进行了详细转录和主题分析。
在对治疗方案的偏好方面存在个体差异。每周治疗完成者担心密集式治疗可能会令人难以承受或过于短暂,无法实现真正的改变。然而,密集式治疗完成者重视高压和快节奏,并认为这提高了动力、参与度和最终结果。
对于选择接受密集式治疗的 OCD 服务使用者来说,密集式治疗方案可作为 CBT 的有效且可接受的治疗方案。密集式治疗后,提供高质量的随访和危机支持可能尤为重要。