Papuga M Owen, Burke Jeanmarie R
New York Chiropractic College, Seneca Falls, NY, USA.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2011 Feb;34(2):114-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jmpt.2010.12.008.
An ink pad and paper, pressure-sensitive platforms, and photography have previously been used to collect footprint data used in clinical assessment. Digital scanners have been widely used more recently to collect such data. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the intra- and interrater reliability of a flatbed digital image scanning technology to capture footprint data.
This study used a repeated-measures design on 32 (16 male 16 female) healthy subjects. The following measured indices of footprint were recorded from 2-dimensional images of the plantar surface of the foot recorded with an Associate Platinum (Foot Levelers Inc, Roanoke, VA) digital foot scanner: Staheli index, Chippaux-Smirak index, arch angle, and arch index. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) values were calculated to evaluate intrarater, interday, and interclinician reliability.
The ICC values for intrarater reliability were greater than or equal to .817, indicating an excellent level of reproducibility in assessing the collected images. Analyses of variance revealed that there were no significant differences between raters for each index (P > .05). The ICC values also indicated excellent reliability (.881-.971) between days and clinicians in all but one of the indices of footprint, arch angle (.689), with good reliability between clinicians. The full-factorial analysis of variance model did not reveal any interaction effects (P > .05), which indicated that indices of footprint were not changing across days and clinicians.
Scanning technology used in this study demonstrated good intra- and interrater reliability measurements of footprint indices, as demonstrated by high ICC values.
之前曾使用印台和纸张、压敏平台以及摄影来收集用于临床评估的足迹数据。近年来,数字扫描仪已被广泛用于收集此类数据。本研究的目的是评估平板数字图像扫描技术采集足迹数据的评分者内和评分者间信度。
本研究对32名(16名男性和16名女性)健康受试者采用重复测量设计。使用Associate Platinum(Foot Levelers Inc,弗吉尼亚州罗阿诺克)数字足部扫描仪从足底二维图像中记录以下测量的足迹指标:斯塔赫利指数、奇波-斯米拉克斯指数、足弓角度和足弓指数。计算组内相关系数(ICC)值以评估评分者内、日间和临床医生间信度。
评分者内信度的ICC值大于或等于0.817,表明在评估所采集图像时具有出色的可重复性水平。方差分析显示,各指标在评分者之间无显著差异(P>0.05)。ICC值还表明,除足迹指标之一足弓角度(0.689)外,所有指标在日间和临床医生之间均具有出色的信度(0.881 - 0.971),临床医生之间具有良好的信度。全因子方差分析模型未显示任何交互作用(P>0.05),这表明足迹指标在日间和临床医生之间没有变化。
本研究中使用的扫描技术在足迹指标的评分者内和评分者间信度测量方面表现良好,高ICC值证明了这一点。