Department of Special Education, National University of Tainan, Tainan, Taiwan, ROC.
Res Dev Disabil. 2011 May-Jun;32(3):1052-7. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2011.01.028. Epub 2011 Feb 21.
This study focused on a comparison of the visuo-spatial abilities (correct rate and speed) between dyslexic and normal students in Taiwan and Hong Kong. There were a total of 120 10-12 year old students. Thirty students had been diagnosed as dyslexic in Taiwan (T.W. dyslexia) and thirty students had been diagnosed as dyslexic in Hong Kong (H.K. dyslexia). Overall, 30 of the Taiwanese participants (T.W. normal) and 30 of the Hong Kong participants (H.K. normal) had received no special education. Dyslexic individuals were diagnosed by the doctors' clinical determination. The material was designed using Autodesk 3ds Max. The participants rotated 3D figures by themselves to find a ball. The results indicated that there was very little difference between dyslexic and normal students. However, the most significant difference between dyslexic and normal student was answering speed, especially in the combined data and the male data. An one-way ANOVA test indicated that in terms of rate and answering speed there was no difference between the H.K. and the T.W. dyslexics. Similar results were also found for the students with normal reading abilities in T.W. and H.K. The criterions for defining the visuo-spatial abilities of dyslexia students appear to be similar in Taiwan and Hong Kong. In addition, there is no difference between students' visuo-spatial abilities even though Chinese literacy instructions differed in the two areas.
本研究聚焦于比较台湾和香港的读写困难学生和正常学生的视空间能力(正确率和速度)。共有 120 名 10-12 岁的学生参与了研究。其中 30 名学生被诊断为台湾地区的读写困难学生(T.W. 读写困难),30 名学生被诊断为香港地区的读写困难学生(H.K. 读写困难)。总的来说,30 名台湾地区的参与者(T.W. 正常)和 30 名香港地区的参与者(H.K. 正常)没有接受过特殊教育。读写困难的个体是由医生的临床诊断确定的。材料是使用 Autodesk 3ds Max 设计的。参与者自己旋转 3D 图形来寻找一个球。结果表明,读写困难学生和正常学生之间的差异很小。然而,读写困难学生和正常学生之间最显著的差异是答题速度,尤其是在综合数据和男性数据中。单向方差分析表明,在速度和答题速度方面,香港和台湾地区的读写困难学生之间没有差异。在台湾和香港地区,阅读能力正常的学生也有类似的结果。读写困难学生视空间能力的定义标准在台湾和香港似乎是相似的。此外,即使在两个地区的中文识字教学存在差异,学生的视空间能力也没有差异。