Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, 55 Fruit Street, White 535, Boston, MA 02114, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2011 Mar 2;93(5):e16. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.J.00489.
An orthopaedic workforce shortage has been projected. The purpose of this study is to analyze the supply side of this shortage by ascertaining the career plans of current orthopaedic residents, comparing these plans with the career patterns of practicing orthopaedists, and identifying career-plan differences according to sex.
An online, self-administered survey was e-mailed to U.S. orthopaedic residents in postgraduate year three or higher, querying them about their fellowship specialty choice and their career plans.
A total of 498 residents completed the online survey; 430 respondents (86%) were male, sixty-three (13%) were female, and five (1%) did not provide information regarding sex. Ninety-one percent of the residents were planning to enroll in a fellowship, with some respondents indicating more than one subspecialty choice: 28% intended to choose sports; 21%, arthroplasty; 14%, hand surgery, 12%, trauma; 8%, pediatrics; 8%, shoulder and elbow surgery; 8%, spine surgery; 6%, foot and ankle surgery; and 2%, oncology. With regard to the top career priorities of residents in selecting a fellowship specialty, 40% indicated intellectual priorities; 36%, educational; 21%, lifestyle; and 4%, economic. Significantly more women than men were planning on pursuing a pediatric fellowship (24% versus 6%, respectively, p < 0.05) and significantly fewer were planning on pursuing a sports fellowship (11% versus 31%, respectively, p < 0.05). Significantly more women than men planned on a subspecialty-only practice (62% versus 34%, respectively, p < 0.05). The projected retirement age of sixty-four years for current residents is roughly equal to that of the previous generation. There was no difference between men and women with regard to leadership and research aspirations, projected retirement age, and projected workdays per week. However, significantly more women than men (65% versus 47%, respectively) planned on reducing their work hours or changing to part-time status at some time during their careers. There is a higher percentage of female residents (13%) than female practicing orthopaedists (4%) in the United States.
We should continue efforts to collect workforce data and be proactive to avert or minimize the effect of impending orthopaedic workforce shortages on our patients. Given the trend toward an increasing proportion of female orthopaedists and the higher likelihood that they will reduce their work hours during portions of their career, policymakers should consider training more orthopaedists to ensure patient access to timely, quality orthopaedic care.
预计骨科劳动力将出现短缺。本研究的目的是通过确定当前骨科住院医师的职业规划来分析短缺的供应方,将这些规划与执业骨科医生的职业模式进行比较,并根据性别确定职业规划差异。
向美国三年级或更高年级的骨科住院医师发送了一份在线自我管理调查,询问他们关于专业选择的意向和职业规划。
共有 498 名住院医师完成了在线调查;430 名受访者(86%)为男性,63 名(13%)为女性,5 名(1%)未提供性别信息。91%的住院医师计划参加专业培训,一些受访者表示有多个专业选择意向:28%的人打算选择运动医学;21%的人选择关节置换术;14%的人选择手外科;12%的人选择创伤科;8%的人选择儿科;8%的人选择肩肘外科;8%的人选择脊柱外科;6%的人选择足踝外科;2%的人选择肿瘤学。关于住院医师选择专业培训的首要职业重点,40%的人表示更注重知识;36%的人表示更注重教育;21%的人表示更注重生活方式;4%的人表示更注重经济。计划从事儿科专业的女性明显多于男性(分别为 24%和 6%,p < 0.05),计划从事运动医学专业的女性明显少于男性(分别为 11%和 31%,p < 0.05)。计划只从事专业领域的女性明显多于男性(分别为 62%和 34%,p < 0.05)。当前住院医师的预计退休年龄为 64 岁,与上一代大致相同。男性和女性在领导能力和研究愿望、预计退休年龄以及每周预计工作天数方面没有差异。然而,计划在职业生涯中的某个时间减少工作时间或转为兼职状态的女性明显多于男性(分别为 65%和 47%)。美国的女性住院医师(13%)比例高于女性执业骨科医生(4%)。
我们应继续努力收集劳动力数据,并采取积极措施,避免或尽量减少即将到来的骨科劳动力短缺对患者的影响。鉴于女性骨科医生的比例不断增加,而且她们在职业生涯中的某个时间减少工作时间的可能性更大,政策制定者应考虑培训更多的骨科医生,以确保患者能够及时获得高质量的骨科护理。